MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Two systems (Pentax + Canon) worthwile?
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

I'm a Pentax user for many years, and I like their DSLR's a lot, but I want to use my primes on their native format. Is there someone on this forum who has both Pentax and Canon systems? If so, I would like to hear about your experiences. Is it hard to get used to two systems or do you have no problems at all?

Right now, I'm very interested in the Canon 5D now that the 2nd hand prices are so low. I've seen mint 5D's go for less than 1000 euros with even fewer clicks (700). My idea would be to use the 5D for M42 lenses and ONLY m42 lenses. I would keep using my other Pentax lenses (AF and non-AF, click the link in my sig for a list) on the K20D and K10D.

Good/bad idea? Let me know what you think. I don't think Pentax will come out with a FF camera soon, so this seems to be me the best for the time being.


Reply

I'm very new to DSLRs, and even newer to MF lenses for mine, but I can say that the M42 lenses are likely the most economical choice for the Canon EOS cameras. I say this because the adapters have been consistently less expensive than other mount adapters, and there are a plethora of M42 lenses to be found.

Sorry I can't offer anything towards comparing the two systems, though I hope the above can be of some use to you.


Reply

I think that the 5D can even be found for EUR800~900 or so sometimes! Perhaps you should try the find one in the UK, since the gbp is so low.

In Hongkong a lot of 5D owners are dumping theirs for the 5D mark2.

I also think the 5D will be an excellent camera for MF lenses, due to its huge eyeviewer and FF. So the 20 Flek is really WIDE!


Reply

I think most EOS lens adapters are quite cheap, only a tiny fraction of the cost of the 5D or even of the best quality wide lenses. So there is no need to limit it to M42. Thats the beauty of the EOS mount, it is very adaptable.


Reply

The only problem with M42 and the 5D, seems to be some Takumars (maybe other lenses), the mirroir is blocked by the rear part of the lens. Personnally, my M42>K adapter is 98% time on the K100D, the 2% are when I need the flash, so I put a Pentax KA mount Razz


Reply

Post subject: Two systems (Pentax + Canon) worthwile?

This would mean to me "crop camera + full frame worth while?"
My opinion would be "yes", to see wide angles the way they were meant to be seen on the full frame. And the high resolution crop cameras... wow!
Yes get both.


Reply

Thanks for the valuable responses! I've made up my mind and I will buy a 5D just for my MF lenses. Cannot wait to finally shoot fullframe again. I know that shooting film is shooting fullframe, but it does not really fit into my workflow. And I do not have the patience for a film to be processed and scanned Wink


Reply

Good Idea.
As you already have two good bodies a third in another system would work well
I see no problems, all camera have the same sort of operation and you quickly get used to them even if a few have little things that get on your nerves
The only thing I would consider is to try to hang on a bit. The S/H price of the 5D will fall a lot as more people buy the new model. My local Canon dealer already has 4 S/H 5Ds available and has no waiting list of buyers for them.

http://www.t4cameras.co.uk/
He is advertising them for £825 but will take 5-10% less.


Reply

Thanks for the tip, Rob. I can wait a few weeks to months. It's not like the end of the world if I continue shooting with my Pentaxes. Cool

In the meantime, I'll try to find a few more lenses.


Reply

I'll swich from Pentax if :

1. There can be found another (brand) NEW FF camera body for around 600 euros and if in the same time Pentax will remain with crop sensor cameras only.

2. If so, I'll choose the system that can offer me IS/VR/SR/SSS/whatever with all mounted lenses (or at least with the AF ones).

PS. But I'll keep the Pentax lenses for film photography Very Happy


Reply

Hello,

Personally, i find this a really good choice (i have already started looking at EOS-5D prices in HK Wink ...), since Pentax doesn't seem to be too much interested in FF DSLRs (at least for now).

This way you will be able to enjoy the real focal length of your lenses (which means that a 24mm will have the coverage of a 24mm lens Laughing ) and that you will have a lot of fun playing with DOF ...

Moreover, there are a lot of really nice adapters for Canon bodies (read: Leica and Contax) ...

Best regards


Reply

good choice...and you may try some AF lenses the Canon as well, besides being FF it is the AF that is much better on the Canon than on the Pentax ( K20D much improoved though )


Reply

kuuan hat folgendes geschrieben::
good choice...and you may try some AF lenses the Canon as well, besides being FF it is the AF that is much better on the Canon than on the Pentax ( K20D much improoved though )


Ehh... I don't think I'm ever going to use an AF lens on the 5D. You said it yourself: the AF on the K20D is better. I know what happens when I use my first AF lens on the 5D: I would want more and more, and before I know what happened I have a stash of L lenses in my cupboard Laughing


Reply

eh Spotmatic, only now I see you have both the K10 and K20.
May I ask, how much of an improvement of the AF there is?
- and you have got to use AF lens on the 5D so you can tell us how the AF of the K20D compares to that of the K20D Wink


Reply

kuuan hat folgendes geschrieben::
eh Spotmatic, only now I see you have both the K10 and K20.
May I ask, how much of an improvement of the AF there is?


Well, the difference is not by night and day, but the difference is clearly there. It locks in focus faster, because it does not do the double focus check the K10D does.

Zitat:

- and you have got to use AF lens on the 5D so you can tell us how the AF of the K20D compares to that of the K20D Wink


I think the K20D is as fast as the K20D Razz (Just re-read your sentence).


Reply

Rolling Eyes of course I'd want comparison of AF between 5D and K20D Idea


Reply

I run Canon, Nikon, Olympus DSLRs systems in parallel. One gets used to it quite easily, but it is quite an expensive experience to do so...


Reply

kds315* hat folgendes geschrieben::
I run Canon, Nikon, Olympus DSLRs systems in parallel. One gets used to it quite easily, but it is quite an expensive experience to do so...


still Pentax and Sigma to go, at least!