MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

28mm Vivitar or Takumar?
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Hi!

I'm looking for a companion lens for the Helios 44-2 I already got - and I want to go wider this time.
After looking through the recommendations and the available lenses (and also my budget constraints Very Happy ), I narrowed down my choices between a Vivitar 28mm 2.8 (PK-mount, Close focus version, which I read is the better variant) or an S-M-C Takumar 28mm 3.5 (M42 - either way they will be converted to be used on a Canon 60D). Also, the Takumar is ~twice the price of the Vivitar.

Question is, which one would you recommend? Is the Takumar worth the higher price? Does maybe someone have experience with both lenses?

Thanks in advance!


Reply

(oh, and I totally forgot about a Soligor 2.8 28mm. Any information about that would be also appreciated! Wink )


Reply

Hi Sebastian.
Lots of choice at 28mm, and you can easily adapt OM/NikF/CY mounts to canon too. That means you could consider a zeiss distagon ... however that would be one of the most expensive options.
My own checking out of 28mm lenses on pentax/samsung apsc cameras has prompted me to conclude that it is only the better/best 28mm lenses that are worth considering, based on the notion that the resolution of the rest isn't particularly better than a kit lens, and there is less/little point in sacrificing Af and the typically better colours and contrast of a decent kit lens/kit lens upgrade. So that prompts considering lenses like the "K" or "M" 28mm f3.5's, or the upmarket f2's, from the pentax vintage line up (I'm not familiar with the taks). And other OEM lenses like olympus zuiko 28mm f3.5, nikon F 28mm. The highly regarded Konika hexanon however is, like minolta's, a poor adapt to canon (optical correction required to get infinity focus).
The vivitar f2's have the best rap. A kino made 28mm f2 (22xxxx serial) I had was good.... but not quite good enough to prompt me to keep it. Watch out for sticky iris's with the viv's.
Many 28's are good enough and so cheap they are worth a look eg sigma miniwide II, tokinas, tamron adaptall 28mm f2.5... browse around you can see plenty of good images made with these lenses. Personally I would tend to avoid older 28's - 1970's and earlier, and reseller marques like soligor. Wide angles benefit more from improved coatings on later lenses I think...

Dan Eurritt has done quite a lot of comparison of vintage WA on sony full frame:

http://www.codectest.com/2014/28mm-prime-lens-comparison-shot-on-sony-a7r-second-round


Zuletzt bearbeitet von marcusBMG am Sa März 31, 2018 12:21 pm, insgesamt 6 Male bearbeitet


Reply

SMC K 28/3.5
SMC/S-M-C Takumar
Vivitar 28/1.9
Rokkor 28/2.5 not for EF Sad
Mir-10A
Here's a family shot I've not seen before
https://www.flickr.com/photos/siimvahur/4703334028/


Zuletzt bearbeitet von Lightshow am Fr März 30, 2018 7:10 pm, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

A late Minolta MD 2.8/28 is the best price vs performance.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
A late Minolta MD 2.8/28 is the best price vs performance.

But doesn't adapt to Canon EF without an adapter with optics.


Reply

A Meyer/Pentacon 29mm would be a nice companion to the Helios. They have m42 mount and are not very expensive. The Takumar is probably better, but slower.


Reply

The Meyer/Pentacon 29mm is a poor lens compared to many other options, centrally it is fairly sharp but the edges are awful, even on APS-C and don't improve all that much on stopping down - strong field curvature.


Reply

A better choice than the sigma miniwide I mentioned for your canon 60D is the 24mm sigma superwide II.


Reply

RMC Tokina 2.8/28mm various mounts, even M42 and Pentax. PB Pentacon Prakticar 2.8/28mm perhaps rather then earlier 29mm version. Both choices cheaper then Takumar or Vivitar CF and easily as good (Vivitar gets a bit closer to the object true).


Reply

http://forum.mflenses.com/soligor-12-8-f28mm-21and-versions-t30866.html


Reply

Tamron Adaptall-2 28mm f2.5 - decent, cheap, plenty around, adapts to anything.


Reply

Pancolart hat folgendes geschrieben::
RMC Tokina 2.8/28mm various mounts, even M42 and Pentax.


+1 ! Great bang for the buck!

See here: https://www.flickr.com/photos/chantalrene/albums/72157630430002884


Reply

TrueLoveOne hat folgendes geschrieben::
Pancolart hat folgendes geschrieben::
RMC Tokina 2.8/28mm various mounts, even M42 and Pentax.


+1 ! Great bang for the buck!

See here: https://www.flickr.com/photos/chantalrene/albums/72157630430002884


Impressive pictures!


Reply

Thank you all for all the advice; I'm going to consider them for a while now!