MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Noise, Dynamic Range and Bit Depth in Digital SLRs
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Came across this recent article, Noise, Dynamic Range and Bit Depth in Digital SLRs by Emil Martinec © 2008

http://theory.uchicago.edu/~ejm/pix/20d/tests/noise/index.html

The idea of noise reduction on raw data before debayerisation was particularly interesting; also some comments on pixel efficiency and headroom. Its really worth a read.


Reply

Thanks.


Reply

very good link. I have to read through it a few more times.
I would like to see similar information about the Pentax K10 22 bit ADC. It is a shame they never mentioned it.
Of course Pentax started out with a pretty bad sensor so maybe their 22 bit trick only levelled things out.

I’m thinking about having this piece framed!
‘Other forms of noise reduction which do involve filtering are also performed in some circumstances by some camera models within the camera and before the sensor data are written to the memory card. Examples include high ISO noise reduction on the Sony A700’
‘The problem with these alterations of raw data is that the user cannot turn them off! Image data is irretrievably adulterated by the noise reduction process.’


Reply

Interesting reading.

I can't help but to draw comparisons with high end audio. There also the engineers in digital capture do the signal to noise ratio thing, the dynamic range thing. All very valuable and useful, of course.

But here's what turns out to be true perceptually:
a hard cut off at the bottom of the bit range produces an unnatural cut off in subtle detail. The introduction of noise (dither) to the incoming signal allows the digital system to encode information below the theoretical noise floor. In other words, a slightly noisier system has better apparent resolution.
In the other direction, the hard stop headroom requires recording engineers to be careful not to clip the sound. (Ie, they don't want blown out highlights!) One way they deal with this is through the use of limiters. Properly used, these will improve the subjective sound, but all too often improper use ruins the sound for the afficionado (while making the overall sound more commercial, as the RMS sound level is louder).

Finally, it turns out that the type of filtering used to remove ultrasonic sound has a definite impact on sound. Indeed, there is evidence that ultrasonic frequencies modulate with audible ones in nature, affecting perceived timbre.

I'm just wondering if some of these findings from digital audio have any translation to digital photography. If so, perhaps we've yet to see what a digital capture system is really capable of, even with current pixel map sizes. (In audio, past a certain point the advantage of more bits is in the ability to manipulate them while maintaining the minimum required actual bit depth - manipulation is always destructive. The sampling frequency, which sets the recordable bandwith, on the other hand benefits from being much higher.)


Reply

Nesster hat folgendes geschrieben::
In other words, a slightly noisier system has better apparent resolution.


This touches on psychoacoustics since we do not live in a totally silent or anechoic environment and so expect a degree of background noise. I do recall a comparison between various types of analogue noise reduction systems some time ago where the listeners actually preferred the system with the least reduction due to it sounding more "natural".

Zitat:
Indeed, there is evidence that ultrasonic frequencies modulate with audible ones in nature, affecting perceived timbre.


Not quite ultrasonic but the basis of Yamaha's range of old DX FM synthesisers - I believe the original work was done at Stanford University.

I think you're right though about the parallels between digital audio and photography in that, technology permitting, we will see improvements.


Zuletzt bearbeitet von bob955i am Mi Mai 28, 2008 9:39 pm, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

bob955i hat folgendes geschrieben::

Not quite ultrasonic but the basis of Yamaha's range of old DX FM synthesisers - I believe the original work was done at Stanford University.


If you call the DX7 "old" you make me feel like a wreck, I have one of those! Laughing


Reply

Laughing

It's old to the younger generation Orio.... Laughing

Used on virtually every track between '83 and early '90's.

No mean feat.

Actually, I've got a DX21, a Sequential Prophet 5 rev. 2, Sequential Sixtrak, Drumtraks, an ARP Axxe and Korgs Poly-800, EX-800 and Poly-800 MkII.

The Prophet was made in '79.


Reply

Ah I was a synthesizer maniac in my early 20s.
I still have some: the DX7II-FD, a Oberheim OB-8 with MIDI modification, a Prophet-VS, an ARP Odyssey, and a Roland D-500 and Oberheim Matrix-6R in rackmount version.

Thinking about it, it was for me the same way it is now with old MF lenses versus autofocus: when people was selling the old analogue synths to buy the digital ones and the samplers, I was buying them (I mean the analogues), for almost nothing. I think I got the ARP Odyssey for the equivalent of today's 25 Euros. I got the Oberheim OB-8 for not much more, like 200 or 250 Euros.
Some months ago I found an ARP Odyssey sold on Ebay for close to 1000 Euros...


Reply

I remember that time too - everyone was going for the latest digital wondertoy and offloading their old gear.

Nothing's really changed has it?

Your collection is worth a tidy sum though - the Obie 8, the Prophet and the Oddy in particular.

My Prophet has also been MIDIed.


Reply

bob955i hat folgendes geschrieben::
I remember that time too - everyone was going for the latest digital wondertoy and offloading their old gear.
Nothing's really changed has it?


Nothing. And the strange thing is, I am always on the anti-conventional side of the battle. I guess it's a mind deformation Laughing I always pick the lost causes Laughing

bob955i hat folgendes geschrieben::
Your collection is worth a tidy sum though - the Obie 8, the Prophet and the Oddy in particular.
My Prophet has also been MIDIed.


Yes, I know... and I keep repeating myself that I must not think about selling it to get the 5D MkII.... Laughing


Reply

Orio hat folgendes geschrieben::
I always pick the lost causes Laughing


The majority isn't always right Orio....

I've often felt myself that sometimes it's a mistake to throw out the past to make room for the future.

Re the near legendary 5D MkII - never has a camera had so much to live up to. Laughing