MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Nikon D50 and old manual Nikkors
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Hi folks

I just bought an old D50 cheap and put my old Nikkor-N 2.8/24 on it. I've been using this lens with an adapter on my EOS 450D and it worked perfectly. However, on the D50, turning the aperture ring, the aperture isn't opening/closing. Does this mean this old lens isn't compatible with the D50?


Reply

No, personal experience, but in general you need AI and AI-S lenses for modern Nikons. Here's what Thom Hogan writes
Zitat:
The D50 takes any Nikon F mount lens (well, lenses earlier than the AI manual focus Nikkors damage the mount if you try to put them on the D50, and a few specific lenses won't work on the D50, usually because they have elements that stick into the mirror box and require mirror lock-up).


Reply

Basic Compatibility of Nikon Bodies and Lenses


Reply

Hmm, I think my lens has been AI converted so it should work. I'll take a pic of the lens so I can verify if it has been AI converted.


Reply

A Brief History of Nikon's Meter Coupling Systems (with links to photos)


Reply

Sorry for the blurry picture. This is the Nikkor-N 2.8/24, I thought this was AI-converted, maybe I'm wrong? My understanding was that the D50 would work with an AI lens, but wouldn't be able to meter. I don't understand why the aperture doesn't work when mounted on the D50, but does with the EOS adapter fitted.



Reply

That lens definitely has the AI aperture ring. That arc-shaped tab to the right is what engages a small tab that rotates concentric with the lens mount, located along the exterior circumference of the lens mount. You should be able to see this arc-shaped tab come into contact with the tab along the mount's outer circumference. If the aperture isn't operating, but does when the lens is dismounted, I would look for something inside the camera's mount area that is possibly conflicting with the aperture stop-down arm at the back of the lens. There must be some mechanical interference going on. If the D50 still has the mechanism that engages this arm, make sure it is behaving normally. If it's stuck in one position, well, "there's your problem!"

As far as metering goes, I'm assuming late Nikon digitals still have this tab on the lens mount's circumference. If it doesn't, that means it is dependent on lenses with electrical contacts to provide aperture information. If it doesn't have the tab, then you'll have to do stopped down metering, or perhaps it will work in aperture priority metering? I'm just not familiar enough with the ins and outs of Nikon's DSLRs. It works with the EOS adapter because the EOS cameras will meter a scene in stopped down mode or aperture priority. The exposure may be off as much as two stops, though, because the camera isn't communicating with the lens.


Zuletzt bearbeitet von cooltouch am Do Sep 19, 2013 7:23 pm, insgesamt 3 Male bearbeitet


Reply

That looks AI'd to me -- identified by the tab and the grooves cut into the edge of the aperture ring.

My guess is mounting on D50 actuates the diaphragm lever back of lens; the EOS adapter doesn't; diaphragm operation on EOS adapter is same as unmounted.

Maybe try mounting with lens set at f/min or with lens set at f/max.


Reply

Sounds like a camera problem, not the lens. Perhaps the aperture actuator is faulty or stuck.

I've not had problems mounting or using AI or non AI lenses on my Nikons. And I use them all the time. I used a D40 and now a D3100 & D3200.

An AF lens on an old film body is another thing altogether. Useable but no aperture control

it is AI'd, the holey bunny ears are the giveaway even if you dont see the flanges.


Reply

I'll fiddle with it and hope I ca get it working. If not, I'll return it for replacement, they had several more D50s and D70s for sale.


Reply

Well, I got it working, I jiggled the stopdown lever on the body a few times and now it works perfectly, I expect it had just become stiff through lack of use.



I'm impressed by how noiseless the output is at base ISO and how good the VF is for focusing.

Makes me really annoyed I started my ventures into digital with an ultra-crappy Canon 10D, if only I'd bought a Nikon to begin with.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::

I'm impressed by how noiseless the output is at base ISO and how good the VF is for focusing.

Makes me really annoyed I started my ventures into digital with an ultra-crappy Canon 10D, if only I'd bought a Nikon to begin with.


The D50 was my first dslr. It was instant love, a real joy to use.


Reply

Aanything hat folgendes geschrieben::
iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::

I'm impressed by how noiseless the output is at base ISO and how good the VF is for focusing.

Makes me really annoyed I started my ventures into digital with an ultra-crappy Canon 10D, if only I'd bought a Nikon to begin with.


The D50 was my first dslr. It was instant love, a real joy to use.


Yes, instant love for me too, the way it fits in the hand and the weight are just right for me, and the VF and focusing are great too.

I think I might have to sell some things and save up for a while so I can afford a more modern Nikon.


Reply

Hi Ian, i didn t saw this thread earlier. I still have a Nikn D50, my first DSRL. When you mount an AI, AI-s lens on a Nikon body the aperture goes wide open, all the metering and focusing is done wide open, when you press the shutter the aperture closes to the value set. Nothing happens when you change the aperture with the aperture ring! This is normal, set the D50 to "M" set the shutter speed and set the aperture. Non chipped lenses won t give you the metering on lower bodies like the D50, so you have to set the exposure the good old way, histogram helps.
Interesting how everything is relative, looking through the viewfinder of the D50 after i get used to the D700 is a pain Smile

Tomas


Reply

Hi Tomas

I was fooled a little by the way the aperture ring didn't control the aperture, but there was no difference in exposure between shots at 2.8 and 8, so the aperture wasn't stopping down. Not having another Nikon lens to try, I didn't know if it was a compatibility issue between this particular lens and the body or not. After playing around for a while, it started working and is still working. I think what had happened was the stopdown lever on the body was stuck and after wiggling it back and forth with my fingers it freed up and now it works as it should.

I'd love a D700, 12mp FF is more than enough for me, and the IQ looks superb. I hoped the D600 and D800 would mean cheap D700s on ebay, but they are still 800-1000ukp. Hopefully the price will fall further and I can afford one in future.

I do like the histogram on the D50 so I don't think the lack of metering will be an issue, and I have several handheld meters I can use too. I will probably add a chip to my beloved Nikkor-N 2.8/24 sometime to enable metering however.


Reply

It must have been jammed or something then, good to hear it s working! For what i would get for it i prefer to keep it, my two kids and wife sometimes use it, sometimes i take it with me on my mountain bike, when i want to document the trip i did, for fellow bikers.

The D50 needs a tiny bit more of sharpening in PP then the D70 for example, but the results can be really good. I warmly suggest View NX to "develop" the raw files (NEF), it s free, CNX2 is great but not free.

Tomas


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
Hi folks

I just bought an old D50 cheap and put my old Nikkor-N 2.8/24 on it. I've been using this lens with an adapter on my EOS 450D and it worked perfectly. However, on the D50, turning the aperture ring, the aperture isn't opening/closing. Does this mean this old lens isn't compatible with the D50?


So what was wrong with the 450D?


Reply

What? There's nothing wrong with the 450D, I don't understand your question.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
What? There's nothing wrong with the 450D, I don't understand your question.



Just wondering why you bought a D50 as well, as I would have thought as the 450d is newer would be superior to the D50 which is old in comparison.


Reply

For infrared, EOSes need to be converted, whereas the old 6mp Nikons work without conversion.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
Makes me really annoyed I started my ventures into digital with an ultra-crappy Canon 10D, if only I'd bought a Nikon to begin with.


D50 was available when 10D was announced?


Reply

I bought the 10D secondhand, I could have bought a secondhand Nikon instead.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::


. I will probably add a chip to my beloved Nikkor-N 2.8/24 sometime to enable metering however.


glad you got it sorted!

Have you used a chip before? I get them from tagotech on ebay: Klicke hier, um es auf Ebay zu sehen, less than 20 quid post paid. I can give you programming details as I re-wrote them a while ago..


Reply

I had found the tagotech one from a recommendation on a website I read yesterday, seems like a very good idea to me. When I get one I'll pick your brains. Definitely worth it for my 2.8/24 and 3.5/55 as I love them.

The D50 is great to use, and I'm pleased with the quality of the output for such an old camera.



The infrared works nicely too, so I'm happy.



Reply

so howd'ya do IR? Just put one of them IR black filters over the lens or is it more complicated?