MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Canon 5D questions
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

I'm currently deliberating whether to get the original 5D or the Mark II. I think I will get the latter, but I want to know a bit about the Live View. I have read recommendations about using manual focus lenses in Live View only to prevent the mirror hitting the back of the lenses. My question is if this is a full-time live view, meaning you engage it and the mirror won't come down (even when the camera is switched off) until you tell the camera to do so?

Zuletzt bearbeitet von Spotmatic am Do Feb 17, 2011 6:41 pm, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

Hi Peter..

When the Live View is ON, it works in this way:

1 - Live View is on = the mirror is up and shutter is FULLY OPEN.
2 - triggering the shutter button = the mirror is still up and shutter closes and opens after shot..
3 - shot done = shutter is open, the mirror is still up..

Live View OFF
The mirror returns, the shutter closes...

There is one good trick -- get two matches (or little piece of plastic sticks), put them inside to cock up the mirror and it's going to be permanently open.Wink

tf


Reply

Thanks Stan Very Happy

However, one question still remains: what happens when you shut the camera off in LV mode? I think the mirror comes down, correct?


Reply

I've been curious about Live View too. Is it something that one would use only on a tripod when shooting still life work or is it usable for people/portraits too?


Reply

And what happens if mirror hits lens? some error appear or mirror mechanism can be damaged?


Reply

if you take a 5D, it will be easier to cut the mirror thanks to the lower used price
my 5DII is 1 year and I still think about fixing the mirror as my guarantee is 2 year, I have only 2 or 3 lens that touch


Reply

Spotmatic hat folgendes geschrieben::
Thanks Stan Very Happy

However, one question still remains: what happens when you shut the camera off in LV mode? I think the mirror comes down, correct?


Correct, mirror comes down when turning off the camera.
Anyway, it will not stay on high position all the time, when in liveView mode. After some time, the camera will switch to normal mode with mirror down by it's own. Mirror will go down, too, when changing a mf lens with chipped adapter.

Btw: I think that live view is absolutly fantastic!!!

Klaus


Reply

poilu hat folgendes geschrieben::
if you take a 5D, it will be easier to cut the mirror thanks to the lower used price
my 5DII is 1 year and I still think about fixing the mirror as my guarantee is 2 year, I have only 2 or 3 lens that touch


I think the best thing you can do is shaving the mirror on 5D MkiII ..

It's EASIER because the frame is made from not too hard material whereas the 5D has some harder material used and you can easily break the glass..

Moreover - the mirror on 5DMkII is also made from different material... l

I have shaved the mirror on my 5D MkII and that's was one of the happiest days ...

tf


Reply

Thanks for the invaluable insights, guys!

However, I'm now leaning again to the MkI. Because it will be my 2nd cam only (my K-5 does everything else, such as Live View and 1080p movies). The 5D's sensor is more than good enough, I just need to make sure that I'll get the right version (no 5D with serial number starting with 1 because these early ones have washed out LCD's).

Or... are there very good reasons to buy a MkII instead?


Reply

What happens when you combine this:
exaklaus hat folgendes geschrieben::
Correct, mirror comes down when turning off the camera.
Anyway, it will not stay on high position all the time, when in liveView mode. After some time, the camera will switch to normal mode with mirror down by it's own.
with this:
shauttra hat folgendes geschrieben::
And what happens if mirror hits lens? some error appear or mirror mechanism can be damaged?

Question

Is it possible to re-engage the live-view mode (and re-raise the mirror) if the mirror has hit the lens on its way down, or does this cause an error to the camera? Question


Reply

Spotmatic hat folgendes geschrieben::

Or... are there very good reasons to buy a MkII instead?


Cause you deserve the very best!!!! Very Happy

and yes I can shoot many of the exakta mounts too with liveview!
something reserved for only the aps-c canons before the "FF" mkII liveview

I also have the "Zacuto 3x finder" which i absolutely love!


Zuletzt bearbeitet von Bruce am Do Feb 17, 2011 3:27 am, insgesamt 4 Male bearbeitet


Reply

Scheimpflug hat folgendes geschrieben::
Is it possible to re-engage the live-view mode (and re-raise the mirror) if the mirror has hit the lens on its way down, or does this cause an error to the camera? Question


Just unscrew/detach the lens from the camrea and the mirror goes back up [or down] on its own, ready to go again! Very Happy
at least this is how its always workes for me. I do try to shy away from lens that are not compatible with the 5D, but I am always too busy not paying attention and I have so many mf lens that need shooting!!! hahaha

I stick a mirror at least once a week [maybe 100 times], but no problems for me yet! Very Happy

The only problems I have ever experienced is with some chipped adapters, then I just tear off the chip with my fingernails so Im back in business! These problems are more of the electrical mishap, not of the mechanical mirror swing issue.


Reply

The mki and ii are worlds apart. I rarely use live view, but the camera seems much more modern and lacks the dust magnet and impossible LCD and crappy menu system.

Oh an the mki doesn't use batteries as it's coal powered. Laughing


Reply

LOL!

I'm still leaning to the 5D MkI though. It's not a bad camera as it seems, provided that you get one with the right serial number (the last versions had a much better LCD, not the one with washed out colors). And of course it's only 50% of the price of the MkII.

I thought the MkI was steam powered? I learned something new every day Razz


Reply

Well, I have now found a 5D Mark I body with the good LCD display (later type). Only drawback: there are 50,000 actuations on it and marks on the flash shoe (black paint worn off). Other than that it looks fantastic because it's never been used outside, was a tripod camera, and the same lens was always mounted on it (so virtually no dust on the sensor).

Apparently the batteries are bad so I can buy the set (which is complete with everything except the box) for EUR 550.

Do/don't? Very Happy


Reply

seems a good deal, certainly less than 50% of MK2
50000 is ok, but I don't think you can verify if this number is true
even if you have to replace the shutter in 3 months, it is still a good deal
batteries in not a problem
if you have 2000 euros, take a MK2 Razz


Reply

Thanks Poilu. It looks like it's a good seller because he was very responsive and up front about the camera. It's a plus I can check it out before purchasing.

So no MkII for me this time Razz


Reply

BTW: that 550 EUR 5D is also with the original Canon BG-E4 grip.


Reply

ok --

I would definitely go for 5DMkII as the liveview may be critical where you must bend your back and you are not willing to use your bum' to sit on the dirty floor -- to be honest -- you can not pay for LiveView as this feature TRULY shows DOF in all measures whereas viewfinder can not simply shows this ..

Someone would say that viewfinder is a only the TRUE PHOTOGRAPHY and using LiveView is not very comfortable -- I would say that LiveView simply SHOWS all areas clearly and truly (including all aberrations!!!) with all details in focus, in front of the focus, out of the focus areas... The comparison to the focusing on the big glass plate - used for large photography is LiveView a real step back to the perfect focusing on big glass -- impossible with 35 mm format..

there is a little BUT -- the pixel pitch is bigger on 5D - which may be critical when the diffraction starts showing its bad side -- the 5D is better --

another 'but' again -- how many times would you use high aperture where diffraction may occur?

ehmm

tf


Reply

LiveView!! Smile



Reply

LOL Stan!

I finally have decided to get the MkI. My next FF will be a mirrorless one Smile

Let's say that there will be something in it for you too. Because I *finally* want to have my FD 85/1.2 S.S.C. Aspherical converted Very Happy

Here are the photos of the MkI in question. Looks good?









Reply

congrats!

and 5D is a great camera -- I have tried this gem and it rocks...

Just one thing -- you need to shave the mirror for converted 85 f1.2 APSH.

S


Reply

As lovely as your pictures may be, they're far too big!


Reply

Oops! Resized them to 1024px wide.

trifox hat folgendes geschrieben::
congrats!

and 5D is a great camera -- I have tried this gem and it rocks...

Just one thing -- you need to shave the mirror for converted 85 f1.2 APSH.

S


No problem at all; I fully know that I have to shave the mirror. That was my intention and such a "cheap" 5D is easier for me to modify than a 3x more expensive MkII Very Happy


Reply

congratulations! i simply love my 5d, it is a wonderful tool and you will appreciate it in candlelight at iso 1600 with a planar 50 or 85/1.4! wow, you just cant beat this cam and planar combos in low light.

in good light, it is also wonderful...btw, you do not have to shave mirror with planar 85/1.4! Very Happy