MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Carl Zeiss Planar T* 50mm F1.7 on 5d2
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Hi

pebbleplace.com has this listed as "iffy". The M42->5D list says that a Chinese adaptor worked fine, but a Fotodiox one it hit the mirror. Anyone with some experience care to comment. I'm interested in this lens.


Reply

I don't think that the 50:1.7 is touching the mirror, but I cannot verify it because my mirror is shaved Very Happy


Reply

It hit the mirror on my 5D MII. I cut the offending piece off the lense and it works fine now. I very much like the pictures it produces.


Reply

I had no problem, as long as I was using a decent adapter. I have tried MM and AE.


Reply

ManualFocus-G hat folgendes geschrieben::
I had no problem, as long as I was using a decent adapter. I have tried MM and AE.


Thanks guys -- okay, now the obvious question: links to MM and AE adapters? Is this what I'm looking for?

I should probably shave my mirror but I'm quite a chicken.

Thanks


Reply

And while I've got everyone here, I'd like to ask about the quality of this lens as well as the Planar 1.4. When reading around in terms of current mount, I've heard mixed reviews of the newer version of this lens. The consensus seems to be to save up and get the Makro-Planar 2/50 which is top notch. Anyone care to comment? I guess price would have a lot of weight here. I don't mind spending up for a lens I'll use a lot. Sometimes I need something I'm not afraid to get messed up though, which is why I'm leaning towards something like this. The Makro-Planar 2/50 is on the list though, for when I have some extra dough.


Reply

I much prefer the 50/1.4 due to the shorter minimum focusing distance, and light gathering ability.

The 50/1.4 is stunning from f/2.8 and provides sharpness across the image at infinity, literally thrashing other 50mms I own. It gets beaten by a lowly Canon EF 50/1.8 in a wall chart resolution test, but in practice the Zeiss images are way nicer with incredible pop.


Reply

kiss-o-matic hat folgendes geschrieben::
And while I've got everyone here, I'd like to ask about the quality of this lens as well as the Planar 1.4. When reading around in terms of current mount, I've heard mixed reviews of the newer version of this lens. The consensus seems to be to save up and get the Makro-Planar 2/50 which is top notch. Anyone care to comment? I guess price would have a lot of weight here. I don't mind spending up for a lens I'll use a lot. Sometimes I need something I'm not afraid to get messed up though, which is why I'm leaning towards something like this. The Makro-Planar 2/50 is on the list though, for when I have some extra dough.


I can't compare it to the Makro-Planar but it's a really sharp lens, has great colours and great coatings.

I use it mostly stopped down, it's my "boring lens" for when I don't care about interesting rendering, I just want to capture exactly what I see.

Here's a couple of samples at f/8.

fall colours at infinity


coatings torture test


Reply

Okay, sorry for the late reply. I've had a lot of "stuff" going on.

I wound up getting this lens. For short distances, it's really nice and I'm very happy with it. It was like $200, and very sharp. However, there are two caveats which might be a deal breaker for me taking it out much.

- It does not focus to infinity w/ either of the two adapters I tried (Rainbow Imaging and some really cheap one). Is it worth trying a FotoDiox. I had the same deal w/ Rokkor 58mm. I assume this has to do w/ the adapter keeping the lens too far away from the sensor?

- With the Rainbow Imaging adapter, the aperture blades sometimes get stuck. I can freely move the ring from left to right, but the blades generally get stuck somewhere at F4 or F5.6. If I take the adapter off, no problem. Using the cheapy other adapter, it's worse: the blades don't move at all.

I'm actually thinking of getting a cheap Aria body so keeping the lens would make sense, I guess. It would be cool if I could use it on the 5d2 to it's full potential. Otherwise I might look at a the SMC Takumars in similar focal distances. I still may shell out and get the 50mm MP. Smile


Reply

I had a similar aperture problem with my new 50/1.4 (AE) only in my case if I opened the aperture it would open up all the way.

As I was new to the lens I'd accidentally touch the aperture ring instead of the focus ring, and the thing would pop wide open. This was fixed by taking the lens off the camera (or just off, enough to reset the aperture). When the lens was actually off the camera everything worked as it should.

My adapter was bought from yeenon_cn on eBay, and it works fine on my other C/Y lenses - I tried it. So I do not think it is the adapter that is the problem, nor the 5Dii, since it works with the other CY lenses; rather it is this lens, perhaps? Anyone else have a comment?

I've had no problems with the 50/1.7 - a great lens!!