MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Best Developers for Ilford HP5, FP4, Agfa Copex HDP13
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Hi folks

I just picked up some cheap bulk rolls of film, Ilford HP5 and FP4 and Agfa Copex HDP13 microfilm (same as Adox CMS 20).

FP4 sucks in RO9 so I'm wondering what people have used with this film that works well and gives nice deep blacks. I'm guessing Ilford dev will be best, but which one - ID-11, Perceptol, Microphen, Ilfosol 3?

Also, what would be best for the Agfa? It's a slow very high resolution film so I'm wondering if it will need a particular dev?


Reply

If that Agfa Copex is really same as Adox CMS20 (which is very probable), I would try the original Adox developer ADOTECH II which is optimized for this high-resolution film. Using another developer is possible, but you won´t get the best what this film can offer in terms of tonality and grain.

When you´re talking about "R09" you mean Foma clone of Rodinal? I´ve tried few rolls of FP4+ in original Agfa Rodinal and all of them came good, full tonality from deepest blacks to highest whites, but pretty grainy though (1+50 dilution).

If you want really short steep tonality with deep blacks, try Koblic MPB developer - it needs mixing from pure chemicals, but it produces really interesting results.

I cannot give an advice on HP5+ as I use Tri-X as my ISO400 film.


Reply

That Adox developer isn't available in the UK, or at least, I can't find it.

The RO9 I used isn't made by Foma. I dev'd a few rolls of FP4 in it, gave only okay results, all shades of gray with no proper blacks or whites. Grain was okay. I had to boost the contrast a lot in PP to get a nice looking result. Fomapan in RO9 is 10x better than FP4, hence I asked what others had used.

FP4+ in RO9, had to pump up the contrast a lot in Photoshop:



Fomapan 100 in RO9:




Reply

I found Adolux here:
http://www.ag-photographic.co.uk/adox-adotech-ii-861-p.asp

ad. R09 (which is Rodinal clone and behaves almost identical): according to manufacturer´s information and my experience, rodinal isn´t a low-contrasty developer. so my question is, at which sensitivity did you develop the film; and what dilution, time and agitating you used? do you evaluate developed film from prints or scans? because there is a huge difference between development times for printing and scanning - film developed for printing is pretty hard to scan because contrast is too low, and vice versa

look here for some tips on development times:

http://www.digitaltruth.com/devchart.php?Film=FP4&Developer=&mdc=Search


Reply

Ian - Try 1:50 Rodinal for FP4. Invert twice every 60 seconds. This is how I use it for all films and I never get blacks blocking up, even with Pan-F.


Reply

That's how I used the RO9, 1:50, I didn't keep any of the raw scans to show you why I didn't like the results, sadly.


Reply

well I think that problems lies in scanning - you must adjust developing procedure for your scanning workflow to get results you want.


Reply

No, fault lies with the film/dev combo, FP4 in RO9 gives inferior results to Fomapan 100 in RO9, hence my question.


Reply

hi

You might try LC29, which gives very contrasty negatives, you have 3 dilutions available : 1+29 ( eco one ) 1+19, the middle, and 1+9 only for the braves Wink. the less diluted, the more contrasty neg gets, as with Rodinal/R09 for 1+25 1+50 etc

And there's also Ilfosol 3 ; a developer i use lately. Wille give maybe less contrasty negs, but pushing the dev by 1min of the indicated time can solve it. That said if there's only the scan issue and negs afterwards, i think we all deal with it, scan quite destroys negatives, so you have to post treat. Or print Very Happy


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
No, fault lies with the film/dev combo, FP4 in RO9 gives inferior results to Fomapan 100 in RO9, hence my question.
okay;)


Reply

berraneck hat folgendes geschrieben::
iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
No, fault lies with the film/dev combo, FP4 in RO9 gives inferior results to Fomapan 100 in RO9, hence my question.
okay;)


Do I really have to re-scan some negs to prove it to you?


Reply

I had same experience with ILFORD + Rodinal than Ian had, simple not good. Need to use more matched developer.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
Do I really have to re-scan some negs to prove it to you?
that´s not needed, I believe that you got bad results while scanning the film. but I do not think it´s a problem of film/dev combo - negative for scanning just needs more exposition and longer developing to maintain results simmilar to darkroom prints; so if you used time/dilution/agitation suggested for normal process where darkroom printing is involved, you simply cannot get good results with scanning this film. I was also trying to scan some of my BW negs - which were developed propperly and in darkroom produced really nice prints; but when I tried to scan them it didn´t produced any good scans. hope it´s understable, my english sometimes sucks:)


Reply

I don't know the technical terminology to properly describe the issue, I had a wide range of tones with FP4, but they were all grays, from light gray to dark gray, no proper black and no proper white. I tried different dev times and methods with both 120 and 35mm FP4 rolls in RO9, I tried little agitation and lots of agitation, even 1:100 stand dev.

Fomapan 100 came out a lot nicer in RO9, so I think Foma and RO9 is a good combo.

I have 30m of FP4, 30m of FP4+ and 17m of HP5 so I have more than enough to work out the best developer by trial and error, just wondered what dev had given best results with these Ilford films for other people.

I ran out of the RO9 I had, so now I just have Fomadon (Rodinal copy) Paterson FX-39 (which I bought for use with TMAX 100 as it's designed for T-grain films like TMAX, Delta, APX) and Celer-Stellar which is designed for chromagenic films like XP2.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
I don't know the technical terminology to properly describe the issue, I had a wide range of tones with FP4, but they were all grays, from light gray to dark gray, no proper black and no proper white. I tried different dev times and methods with both 120 and 35mm FP4 rolls in RO9, I tried little agitation and lots of agitation, even 1:100 stand dev.

Fomapan 100 came out a lot nicer in RO9, so I think Foma and RO9 is a good combo.

I have 30m of FP4, 30m of FP4+ and 17m of HP5 so I have more than enough to work out the best developer by trial and error, just wondered what dev had given best results with these Ilford films for other people.

I ran out of the RO9 I had, so now I just have Fomadon (Rodinal copy) Paterson FX-39 (which I bought for use with TMAX 100 as it's designed for T-grain films like TMAX, Delta, APX) and Celer-Stellar which is designed for chromagenic films like XP2.


+1


Reply

Line around the bollard says it all. Why would anyone want to stray from that result?


Reply

Ian try the Ornano Gradual ST-20, it's an excellent developer which beats Rodinal hands down for contrast, as this test review by Nadir magazine also shows:
http://www.nadir.it/test/FUJI_NEOPAN/fuji_neopan-ss.htm

You can find it in several italian shops, this is a nice seller, lives near to me, you can order directly or if you prefer, I can add a bottle to my next order to him, then relay it to you:
http://www.westernphoto.it/catalogo/ORNANO_GRADUAL_ST20_1_litro_


Reply

Wow, that is some nice results and comparative between it and Rodinal.


Reply

Cheers orio, I might just have to get some of that soon, I'll be in touch.

Cheers Bill, the Fomapan in RO9 came out great at 1:50, I just wish I had lots of Fomapan then I'd stick to that, just the Ilford films turned up cheap so I grabbed them, 107m of BW film should keep me going for quite a while!

The Agfa microfilm really intrigues me, I'll be sure to send you some with the Sporti.

Zitat:
If you are looking for a (very) high resolution and (very) contrasty Black and white film, you have probably looked at Agfa Copex Rapid film already, but have not ordered it because it’s high price (about EURO 6,– per Roll). I got some testrolls recently from Maco Direct to try how it behaves in caffenol. This film is not so easy to handle and there is not so much information about it, as it is specified as microfilm and can be used in x-ray cameras. Resolution is about 600 lines/mm (Fuji Velvia 50 is rated to resolve 160 lines per millimeter) so the film will outperform any Lens you have, easily. It complies to ISO 10602 and has a life expectance of 500 years. The Film base is made of PET and curls like Hell, even if you hang it with film weights. The emulsion scratches easily when wet, so please give this film a good wash before you wipe it, or don’t wipe it at all.


Reply

Katastrofo hat folgendes geschrieben::
Wow, that is some nice results and comparative between it and Rodinal.


Bill, Ornano products are very good quality and relatively low priced (at least here in Italy)
The same offer I made to Ian is also valid for you obviously. I will be making an order soon to the near shop here, for C41 processing chemicals.
Should you like to try the Gradual ST 20, or the cheaper ones STD and Fino S31, let me know, you will not pay shipping from shop to here,
only shipping from me to USA (hopefully customs will not be difficult with chemicals?)

They also sell directly worldwide and have shop versions for dollars and pounds (see upper left):
http://www.westernphoto.it/sell-online
don't know about their foreign shipping rates though.

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
Cheers orio, I might just have to get some of that soon, I'll be in touch.


ok, I'll be ordering soon from them, so if you are interested in anything, you can have a look at their site and let me know now.


Reply

Thanks Orio, I'm a bit strapped for cash right now after buying all the film and having 5 buyers returning lenses for refunds on ebay Sad

I have lots of Fomadon and Paterson FX-39 to work with, if those don't give me good results I'll be in touch.

It sucks being a penniless peasant...


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
having 5 buyers returning lenses for refunds on ebay Sad


Dang! Shocked what went wrong?


Reply

Orio, thanks for the kind offer, but will pass for now. I'll be shooting a lot more color than BW, going into
summer.

Looking forward to what you will do with the C-41 chems!


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::


The Agfa microfilm really intrigues me, I'll be sure to send you some with the Sporti.


Ian, thanks, will be happy to try it! I've been meaning to make a batch of D23, see how it goes.


Reply

Orio hat folgendes geschrieben::
iangreenhalgh1 hat folgendes geschrieben::
having 5 buyers returning lenses for refunds on ebay Sad


Dang! Shocked what went wrong?


Well, one guy returned a Tamron fisheye c-mount due to a 1.5mm scratch I hadn't noticed, he is quite an offensive chap, another is upset about a Pentacon 135mm with oil on the blades, another is threatening court action (last msg 'I'll see you in court, do not communicate with me again') over the Fujinon 1.6/55 I sold, he didn't read the description where I mentioned the grease on the front element and showed large photos of the grease, etc etc. I just seem to have run into a spate of crazy buyers. The worst of the lot is a fellow in the far east who returned this Tessar because he said it was full of fog and had a damaged filter ring, he says he hasn't had his refund Sad This guy had me send him RAW files before he would pay and then shoot a roll of film with it too, finally he paid then screamed blue murder when he got it that I had sold him junk! Twisted Evil



I am looking forward to what you do with the C-41 too, please post results and experiences.

I'll get the Sportis tested over the next couple of days Bill and load you up some cartridges of the Copex, be great to see what you can do with it.