MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Nex-5n v EOS 60D high ISO
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

OK, first off, this is a hard test to conduct. Both cameras have different crop factors AND resolutions.

Test setup: Both cameras were set up on a tripod with timer. I moved the Sony in slightly closer as it has a 1.5x crop factor as opposed to the Canon's 1.6x crop factor. The same lens was used in both cases, a Nikkor 28/2 non-ai version @ f/5.6. All shots focused with liveview. Sony shots were a bit wonky Laughing

I cropped the Canon images to the same size as the Sony images, so the images are roughly comparable. No resizing or sharpening or noise reduction has been applied (apart from the Adobe RAW defaults which is the same for both anyway). I shot under horrible tungston light to make it realistic.

Canon EOS 60D @ ISO 3200



Sony Nex-5n @ ISO 3200



Canon EOS 60D @ ISO 3200 - 100% crop



Sony Nex-5n @ ISO 3200 - 100% crop



Canon EOS 60D @ ISO 6400



Sony Nex-5n @ ISO 6400



Canon EOS 60D @ ISO 6400 - 100% crop



Sony Nex-5n @ ISO 6400 - 100% crop



To me, the Sony shots are less noisy. Both cameras performed well IMO.


Reply

Not a lot in it but the Sony does have it by a little imho


Reply

Nooooo my 60D sucks Sad Evil or Very Mad


Reply

ManualFocus-G hat folgendes geschrieben::
No resizing or sharpening or noise reduction has been applied (apart from the Adobe RAW defaults which is the same for both anyway)


You should turn it off. That way, the results are not neutral. ACR's noise reduction is a standard noise reduction (of the butcher's type) that affects in the same way two cameras that are different and require different treatment.
So in my view, either you turn noise reduction off completely, or, you apply it customly for each camera the best way possible using a specialized software (such as Noise Ninja or Nik's software).


Reply

Wow, this is really interesting to me as I mainly shoot live bands. So low-light action which requires good iso handling.

I shoot Nex5 and Pentax Kx. Out of those two the Nex wins, way less grain. However I have a mate/competetor who shoots a 60D and he seems to kill me everytime. His shots are so clean and crispy without an ounce of grain. It's like they are shot at 200iso. Now seeing these results, it makes me wonder how he does it. He must be a master of PP. mind you mine is the Nex5 and not the upgraded Nex5n, so that could be making all the difference. Very Happy


Reply

I recently have received some unexpected funds from my insurance proceedings and from my father's postal bonds.
So I was able to invest some money into equipment.
One of the things I bought, 10 days ago, at the camera fair in Castel San Giovanni, was a Canon 60D, brand new, for 800 Euros.
I had missed a APS-C camera since I sold the 50D. It is very useful for me when shooting live events because I can use small teles
and get big enlargements. With the 18MP, the 60D offers me more than what I would achieve by simply cropping a 5DMkII photo.

I was in fact undecided between the 60D, a 7D, or a Sony Nex.
I ruled out the Sony Nex because the disadvantage of focusing with an LCD and of having to buy a whole set
of (expensive) adapters would overcome the advantage of being able to use rangefinder lenses (something that I can do on the M9).
The choice between the 60D and the 7D was determined by the difference in price (a brand new 7D from the same seller would have costed me 500 Euros more),
by the fact that with the new generation of adapters I don't need focus microadjustment in camera anymore, and by the important circumstance that on the 60D I can mount
the Ef-S focusing screen (optimized for manual focus), something that the 7D does not allow.

In these last 10 days, I have tested the 60D under a series of circumstances, and I have been absolutely delighted by the use of the camera and by the results.
Note that I am a 5D Mark II owner, so my expectations are set to a quite high level.

My experience with high ISO on the 60D is completely different from that of Shrek.

This is a 4000 ISO snapshot that I took of my cat Ermione in horrible and weak tungsten light, using a Planar 1.7/50 lens.
The image here is exactly as output by Breezebrowser Pro, which is a program that uses Canon's SDKs to display EOS Raw images.
So it is exactly as Canon intended the images of this camera to be displayed. I did not even develop it, I simply took a screen grab.
The noise reduction was of course turned off in BB Pro and the only thing I did to the image was to resize it to 1024 pixels to fit inside the gallery's limit.
Note how "3D" and volumetric the image still looks in spite of the tungsten lighting and of the 4000 ISO:



Here follow two 100% crops from the developed RAW image. Again, absolutely no parameter was altered and the noise reduction option was set to OFF:




As you can see, there is plenty of detail in the image, the noise presence is really moderate and a wise use of noise reduction would remove it almost entirely without loss of sharpness.

What can I add more? I am delighted. I even have trouble believing that I took these with an APS-C camera dense with 18millions pixels.
It's a 4000 ISO that is totally useable even for detailed reproduction.

And it goes also farther. The 6400 ISO is totally useable as well, as you can see from this other photo, taken at ISO 6400 under tungsten light
(again, original BB Pro display resized to gallery limit, NR set to OFF in BB Pro):



Even 6400 would be useable as is, detail is totally there and noise is unobtrusive. An intelligent noise reduction will make the noise virtually disappear at no detail loss.


Reply

Absolutely awesome Orio!
That looks just like the output my mate is producing from his 60D.
It just seems to handle high iso soooo well!
My Nex is still useable at 6400 though no where as clean as your 60D, ehere as my KX is a mess at 6400...infact even 1600 is horrible...
What makes the 60D output look so clean in comparison, in your oppinion mate?


Reply

Hood;
Nex5N definitely better iso than Nex5
I have Nex5 & my little brother has 60D. his cam has better noise just like your case. itsn't matter of PP.
I like 60D handle than Nex. specially for low light, macro, & long lenses.


Reply

Cheers Iaza. Very Happy

Seems I need a better camera in the future to compete.
But I don't really want to switch to another different system.

I wondet how a K5 stacks up to a 60D? Hmmmmm.... Wink


Reply

Interesting stuff, but the cat shot (which looks lovely by the way!) looks to have had noise reduction applied as there's no real grain? Either that or the JPG compression has had an effect.

Here's one from me at ISO 3200 with the 200/2.8L processed in ACR with no sharpening and no noise reduction:





And another:





Reply

i've actually seen a metter when high ISO noise gets worse with the age of the camera on a canon 550D, as my friend told me about it and thats what he thinks. (he own a 550D)

maybe here the same on a brand new 60D there is not so much noise?

anyway i use solely the 60D and im very used to it, and i know that i can shoot at up to iso 3200, and after PP i will get brilliant pictures, af if shot at maybe 800 iso or so.


Reply

ManualFocus-G hat folgendes geschrieben::
Interesting stuff, but the cat shot (which looks lovely by the way!) looks to have had noise reduction applied as there's no real grain? Either that or the JPG compression has had an effect.


Absolutely no noise reduction in software, and JPG was set at 100% quality.
I can send you the Raw file if you like to see it. Smile
Do not forget that a program like Lightroom/ACR is generic. It is not optimized for Canon cameras.
For critical shots, like ISO 4000 shots, you should always use either Canon's DPP, or Breezebrowser Pro which is equivalent.
It does make a visible difference in image quality.
This is something that people underestimates, but proprietary Raw software has a reason to be and an advantage over generic software.
For low ISO photos I use Lightroom/ACR no problem, but none of my high ISO RAWs is developed by Lightroom/ACR, whose noise reduction sucks.
I either do it in BB Pro, or use Corel AfterShot with Noise Ninja Professional embedded.


Reply

ManualFocus-G hat folgendes geschrieben::
Interesting stuff, but the cat shot (which looks lovely by the way!) looks to have had noise reduction applied as there's no real grain?


Hm... correction.
It seems that BB Pro does apply some noise reduction when developing the RAW even if I set it to "OFF".
That's strange.
So you were right... I will ask the software author about it.


Reply

Just a quick thought...is your camera set to shoot with noise reduction turned on? Obviously most RAW converters would ignore that (it's more a JPG option), but a system like DPP which is attempting to apply in-camera settings may apply it without you asking?

Either way, your comment about DPP is certainly echoed elsewhere and I will try it some time to see if I get better results than with ACR.

Ooh, I almost forgot to say, the 60D has an absolutely amazing LCD screen!


Reply

ManualFocus-G hat folgendes geschrieben::
Just a quick thought...is your camera set to shoot with noise reduction turned on? Obviously most RAW converters would ignore that (it's more a JPG option), but a system like DPP which is attempting to apply in-camera settings may apply it without you asking?


I had no idea it was there, but yes, in the Custom Functions there is a menu option about high ISO NR and it is set to Standard.
So perhaps this is what BB Pro applies and Lightroom not because it's not a Canon proprietary converter.


Reply

My best attempts of conservative NR in Lightroom
(by conservative I mean that I put preservation of detail first and noise reduction second):

Lightroom alone:


Lightroom + Nik's DFine (via Export loop):