MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

film digitization using dslr: advice needed
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

so i find myself taking more and more film pictures and i'm getting tired of paying to have them digitized. for many reasons I HAVE RULED OUT SCANNING either by myself or paying others.

then i saw online that many people digitized their own negatives using a simple lightbox, placing film in a holder i can get from my unused scanners, and quality digicam on a tripod. with the amazing resolution and color accuracy i get from my fuji x100, this now seems like a viable option. once properly set up it would seem to move very quickly in terms of physical workflow. i have lightroom 3.6 as my PP software.

so now for the advice part:

will i get really good quality results?

what should i keep in mind in buying a lightbox and can you recommend one under $100usd?

what setting on lightroom will transpose the negative image to a positive image?

any particular thing or things i need to know to maximize my result?

thank you for your help!
tony


Zuletzt bearbeitet von rbelyell am Do Dez 15, 2011 7:55 pm, insgesamt 2 Male bearbeitet


Reply

I digitise medium format negs with a camera. It works well enough for screen use and moderate enlargement up A4/Letter size. The biggest issue was finding the right lens for the job, ie one with zero barrel distortion. Eventually I settled on a 50mm Minolta enlarger lens.

I've not tried digitising 35mm this way. I use a simple Kodak scanner (P460) which does quick 1200dpi scans of my 35mm negs which are more than good enough to have a record of what I have on file. For any I want to print or show-off to others, I rescan them with an Epson flatbed, but that's not all that often.

The little Kodak is very quick and drags the film through on it's own, so I don't have to sit and wait. It also works without a PC.

Hope that give you a few ideas.


Reply

I get my local processor (camera shop) to process my films and then upload(?) to disc. No prints. That way I can play around to my hearts content in Lightroom etc etc


Reply

trev hat folgendes geschrieben::
I get my local processor (camera shop) to process my films and then upload(?) to disc. No prints. That way I can play around to my hearts content in Lightroom etc etc


Me too at Asda...good enough for a computer screen.


Reply

appreciate the responses, but i'd really even more appreciate if anyone has experience in the areas ive asked about, ie, digitizing through digicam. film holders, simple lightbox and PP hopefully through lightroom 3.6. i am really not interested in scanning either myself or professionally done. thanks!


Reply

Hello, there.
The top notch solution here would be looking for a bargain bellows with matching film duplicating stage, then a macro lens is mandatory for an optimal result. To stay cheap I think an enlarger lens might do, as already suggested, as it's optimized for flat field work.
The right focal length will be depending on the size of the camera sensor, so for 24x36 it'll be a 50 and for smaller formats something shorter than that. The illumination could be provided by a flash, if it is a TTL capable unit that would be the best. An old unit with manual controls will work also, you will have to tune up the exposure by trial and error but once established should stay in the ball park.
The camera plus bellows can be mounted on a tripod, the flash will be operated off camera and positioned on some sort of stand right in front of the duplicating stage. This is one of the projects I'm playing with for making cheap prints out of some of my slides. I'm working with film, but I think it should work great, maybe even better, for your purpose.

Cheers, M.


Reply

You can try with small P&S - I have Canon G9 and it gives good results and slide copier (hollow tube with frame for film + white plastic on the back). Shoot in RAW and then process in Lightroom.

About Lightroom - if you need to digitize slides it is OK, but for negatives (B/W or C41) you need to invert the colors and i couldn't find a 'Negative' function built in Lightroom.

There is one plugin (i will check from where i got it later) which does the negative image but it just inverses the curves so later if you want to adjust exposure or brightness - the sliders have to be moved in opposite direction.


Reply

My setup to scan slides and film is based on a double bellows (Pentax Auto Bellows) with an Helios 44 lens in the middle. It works really well with the NEX (and with all the APS-C cams) because it does allow for a full frame capture on the APS-C cams.
Previously I tried a standard slide duplicator with the 5D, but it was overkill to me to keep the 5D just for scanning.

This is the setup:



The next picture is from 1988 at San Vicente de la Barquera. The original slide was Agfachrome (50 or 100, I cannot remember), shot with my Silette LK sensor. The slide is as it comes out from the cam.



I plan to try with a different lens, in this case the first bellows are almost closed, whilst the second one is fully extended.

The idea came from a friend of mine (Manolo Portillo) a great photographer with a high technical knowledge, to whom I thank here for his unvaluable help:

Manolo's site

Regards.

Jes.


Reply

std hat folgendes geschrieben::
About Lightroom - if you need to digitize slides it is OK, but for negatives (B/W or C41) you need to invert the colors and i couldn't find a 'Negative' function built in Lightroom.


+ you have to remove the orange layer from color negatives, which is #&/%#¤ if the software doesn't know that.

here are some instructions:
http://www.tedfelix.com/Photography/ColorNegative.html


Reply

thanks guys! these are very interesting and good food for thought. let me ask, can this process be done without flash using instead a light box to prvide the light? additionally, can it be done without bellows but rather in 'macro' mode?

btw, re lightroom, i'm wondering if the 'Direct Positive' setting would reverse negative film?


Reply

rbelyell hat folgendes geschrieben::
thanks guys! these are very interesting and good food for thought. let me ask, can this process be done without flash using instead a light box to prvide the light? additionally, can it be done without bellows but rather in 'macro' mode?

btw, re lightroom, i'm wondering if the 'Direct Positive' setting would reverse negative film?


I use bellows and a small flash behind, just to get a small aperture that allows for a wider DOF to get the slide well in focus.
Macro lenses trend to have a very short DOF and may cause problems due to the slight curvature of the film when inside the frame.

Regards.
Jes.


Reply

The point in using a flash is being able to use a reasonably fast speed while using a small aperture (f11 and beyond). You want to use smaller apertures to maximize dof and compensate for small film curvature, at life size the dof is gonna be really shallow. That said I think using a light table is perfectly feasible but the exposure is gonna go biblical unless you have a very powerful light source. The bellows is convenient for the simplicity of adjusting perfectly the frame and keeping all the setup firmly together. In alternative you could try an extension tube and being very creative to arrange all the elements (film holder, light source and camera) in a suitable way.
To get rid of the orange mask you need to open the scan file with an editor (PS or something), then:
1. Create a new layer
2. With the eyedropper tool you pick the color on the unexposed border of the film.
3. Fill the newly created layer with the color from step #2.
4. Set the layer mode to "difference" or "subtract", I'm not sure what it's exactly called in an English localization of the sw.
5. Merge the layers.
6. Invert the colors.
7. Adjust the levels.
Then you might want to play with curves or other to refine further the job.

Cheers, M.


Reply

marty hat folgendes geschrieben::
To get rid of the orange mask you need to ...


yep, this is the #&(/&= part I mentioned Smile


Reply

How about to use cold bulb (energy saving) with proper color temperature (sunlight) instead of flash ?

Clever setup Jes!


Reply

I digitized some old slides of mine with my Konica Minolta A2, a close up lens, a piece of toilet paper roll and PVC pipe and a Cokin filter holder. It was 0 investment and very improvised, but it worked. How I came to it, advices and some documentation see: http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1024&message=26288667

some result:

( the happy boy, that's me Wink

Gaumuk, the origin of the river Ganges:


As light source I used the sun. It was autumn and mostly hazy, very uniform light, I simply held the camera against the window. After sun set I made the screen of my notebook to display white and held my set up as close as possible to the screen Wink



Zuletzt bearbeitet von kuuan am So Dez 18, 2011 12:08 am, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

some really interesting ideas, thanks everyone. i just bought an $8 lightbox on ebay and i will give it a whirl with slides first so i dont have to worry about 'positive/negative' thing. we'll see...


Reply

On a practical level, how many megapixels would be required to achieve a really good quality copy of a neg? I ask as it might be an option if I can't find the scanner I'm after.


Reply

GrahamNR17 hat folgendes geschrieben::
On a practical level, how many megapixels would be required to achieve a really good quality copy of a neg? I ask as it might be an option if I can't find the scanner I'm after.

megapixels doesn't mean nothing, many 4000dpi scanners produce less details than a good 2700dpi
in film times, when a photographer needed to print larger than A3, he used medium format


Reply

yeah, i think (without knowing for sure) that its more about resolving power than pure mp's. thats why i wanted to try it out with the x100--it resolves so well...

i have a lightbox on the way, so we'll see how it goes and i will report back.