MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

AF fast lens or MF ?
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Dilemna or decision...

I would like to have a fast 50mm lens to mount on my 5D MkII.
I had a Canon EF 1.8/50 but gave it to my daughter for her studies.

I'm hesitating between a Canon EF 1.4/50, or a legendary MF fast 50mm, or a modern MF lens thinking especially about the Voïgtlander Ultron 2/40 because of its IQ and it is a pancake.

What's your point of view ?
Thanks in advance for bringing me your advice. Wink

PS : I'd like to get a fast 50mm for street shooting, even in the evening, and for portraits. I don't use and don't like flash.


Reply

A 35mm f/1.4 is a better choice for street shooting in the night than a 50mm
You have the same speed as a 1.4/50 but with a larger field of view (important in cities) and at slow shutter times you have more chances to bring the photo home with a shorter focal lenght.
You can still make portraits (keep aperture open and walk one step closer), and in the daylight, the 35mm gives you some more comfort when shooting hyperfocal than a 50mm.


Reply

Olivier hat folgendes geschrieben::
Dilemna or decision...

I would like to have a fast 50mm lens to mount on my 5D MkII.
I had a Canon EF 1.8/50


Yes, it's an essential attribute of your lovely full frame DSLR. Laughing

Zitat:
but gave it to my daughter for her studies.


And your unmeasured generosity generates a reward in great measure: such lens as you choose. Laughing

Zitat:
I'm hesitating between a Canon EF 1.4/50, or a legendary MF fast 50mm, or a modern MF lens thinking especially about the Voïgtlander Ultron 2/40 because of its IQ and it is a pancake.

What's your point of view ?


My point of view Laughing is that I let go of an EF 50mm 1.8 mk1 to jump at the EF 50mm f/1.4. It's a better piece of kit, af is faster - and quieter - but DoF apart I've never quite been beguiled by it. This, essentially is why I've been experimenting with MF 50mm lenses. But, I was never quite happy with mf for street scene candids.

Then I found a 55mm FL f/1.2 which I had Stan convert to EOS mount and taught myself to shoot in Manual using Live View.

I am now so completely beguiled by this lens that I am standing on the edge of relying on it for street candids and leaving the AF lens at home with a view to actually letting go of the AF lens.

Others have already touched on whether 35mm - or wider - might be better for you depending on what you want to shoot. If you want architecture why not go wider still than 35mm?


Reply

Sigma 1.4/50mm HSM. Better bokeh wide open than EF 1.4/50mm

Wink


Reply

Well, if you are looking for a lens for street candid shots, i wouldn't go for the Ultron 40/2 because you wouldn't focus too fast (small focusing ring) ...

Instead, i would go for an AF 50/1.4 (whether Canon or Sigma, the choice is up to you, i've never had such lenses: since i have no daughter, i still have my EF 50/1.8 MkI on my 5DII Wink ) ...

Otherwise, go for a fast 35mm, which, as already said, offers more DOF wrt a 50mm and maybe a more suitable hyperfocal distance for the kind of shots you are planning to take ...

Isn't this a good excuse to invest in a Distagon 35/1.4 Twisted Evil ?


Reply

Distagon 35 1.4 as Orio said.


Reply

Planar 50/1.4. But then I always say that Laughing


Reply

Oh, thank you all for quick answers.

Attila, Orio didn't mention any 1.4/35mm... Laughing
and I'm sure he will agree with your choice of the Distagon. Wink

Thank you Rolf for suggestig the Sigma. In fact, I find it too huge. I look for a discrete and light lens. Everything under control over Rhine ? Wink

Indy, that's interesting to stress the small focusing ring. I didn't take attention to that detail. I was just looking the very good IQ and the pancake format. Does any pancake have a small focusing ring ?

Tikkathree, I understand your advice is to get a 55mm FL 1.2, or a 35mm or a wider lens such as a 20mm or even the Tamron 17mm for architecture. What about the Canon EF 35mm f2 ?

Distagon 1.4/35 is a choice. I think you mean the Contax one ?
What about the Samyang 1.4/35 ?
In the 35mm range, I have today only 2.5 to 2.8 max apertures : Tamron 2.5/28 ; MC Cosinon-W 2.8/28 ; Pentacon 2.8/29 ; CZJ Flektogon 2.8/35 alu version ; Soligor 2.8/35 ; MIR-1B 2.8/37
And I have a Flektogon 4/20.

In the 50mm range, the Voigtlander 1.4/58 Nokton ?
Graham, what version of the Planar ?

Thanks again to all of you for your help.

You know what ? I was also wondering wether buying a compact Olympus XZ-1 wouldn't be a fine idea for street "decisive instants", and to second my 5D² when I don't want to have a too big camera in hands. Confused


Reply

Now I'm wondering what to consider :

a light and small fast 35mm - 50mm range mounted on the 5D²

or an expert compact such as the Olympus XZ-1, Canon Powershot G12, or Fuji X100... Confused


Reply

What's your budget? Because between the EF 35/2 and the X100, it's not exactly the same price (between the Distagon 35/2 T* and the X100, it is)

This is quite a dilemma Smile You could also take another 50/1.8 + a 35/2 Very Happy


Reply

Olivier hat folgendes geschrieben::
or an expert compact such as the Olympus XZ-1, Canon Powershot G12, or Fuji X100...

why not a mobile, latest have dedicated button and can be used for phone, gps navigation, internet, games, etc...
I use mine if I don't have my dslr

edit... hehe, not the best for street shooting, still big delay when you push the button Laughing


Reply

Ylyad, you're right. Maybe the voice of wisdom ... Smile

Poilu, I use my phone either, when I have nothing else.
The delay after pushing button is really awful. Laughing


Reply

If it's for street shooting without flash ( which i don't practice either ) i'd highly recommand the 1.4 version of the EF lens. It's worth the additional price, just for the built quality, it is a very good lens. I used it on the 5D, but sold in favor of a MF lens : )


Reply

Thanks Olivier Embarassed

Naturally, if you have the money, the 1.4 might be worth the money especially in low-light, especially in AF mode. And for having tried the Sigma, I double Rolf's comment on it, it's really a great lens. But from what you're saying, a doubled 35+50 is really a good choice, and both are quite small and unnoticeable


Reply

Get a Canon 50/1.8 as it's cheap for times when you need AF, get some interesting 50s with any money left. Avoid 35mm as they are the work of the devil....or at least I rarely use them as they are worst of both worlds; not wide enough and too short for any of my uses.


Reply

The business about AF not working in low light is one I have never understood. Only when it's so dark that I cannot see does it stop working and I find it faaaaaaar more accurate than MF indoors.


Reply

Thank you Martin for your point of view about the 35mm.
Interesting. I'll have to test this focal to see what I feel about it. Wink


Thank you Hexi.
Which MF did you choose in replacement of the EF 50mm 1.4 ? Planar ?


Reply

The AF in low-light and wide-open can clearly be a problem on some lenses. I can testify myself for the EF 50/1.8. The camera knows that it's not in-focus, but don't manage to stop the AF motor of the lens appropriately.

Olivier, you were requesting a fast lens. But I double martin, I too think 35 is too close to 50. I had the chance to borrow the EF 24/2.8 and I really loved this lens (OK, APS-C inside) and having both 24 & 50 is my personal preference.


Reply

Thank you Ylyad.

I read some reviews about the 28 to 50mm primes.
The 24mm f2.8 seems a very nice "inexpensive" lens in comparision with all I read before.
Speaking about the Canon's low price 50s, it seems the best is the 50mm f2.5 macro.


Reply

Another hint if you need excellent inexpensive, small street camera with no compromise in image quality take a Samsung NX100 with 20-50 kit lens.


Reply

The 24/2.8 is really lovely. It's really difficult to find used, and generally at prices close to new ones. It's small and lightweight, really good for street shots. A couple of examples from my flickr:
- a full set made only with that lens: http://www.flickr.com/photos/derdide/sets/72157625049893891/ - from landscapes to close-ups, wide open or closed down
- two street shots, same subject, different dates:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/derdide/5155450632/in/set-72157625333250296/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/derdide/5316710573/in/set-72157625128250156

This lens is definitely on my wish list Smile

The 50/2.5, I don't know it. For the other 50mm, you can find a good test (in french) here: http://www.focus-numerique.com/test-1170/objectif-quel-optique-50-mm-choisir-comparatif-7.html


Reply

Thank you Attila.
300€ for this NX-100. Not bad at all. Smile

Merci Ylyad.