MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Crappy noise reduction on 5DmkII
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

How to get rid of crappy noise reduction / artificial sharpening on 5DmkII?
I love shooting jpegs. I tried all menu options, all noise reduction disabled. It still produces this smudgy effect on detail:



Reply

I don't know Pancolart, I never try jpeg on the 5DII Embarassed
switch to raw
even on my Nokia phone I use raw, big difference Very Happy


Reply

I know raw is solution but not for me. I am used to do the job on place. Setting correct WB and so... I cannot work with 250 clumsy RAWS at home after 2 hours shooting. Well let that be last resort.


Reply

Could this just be due to the compression?


Reply

Pancolart hat folgendes geschrieben::
How to get rid of crappy noise reduction / artificial sharpening on 5DmkII?


buy a D700 Wink

Seriously it can be possible, the 5D didn't had any nr options. As on the Nikon, i disabled them all.


Reply

hexi hat folgendes geschrieben::
Pancolart hat folgendes geschrieben::
How to get rid of crappy noise reduction / artificial sharpening on 5DmkII?


buy a D700 Wink

Seriously it can be possible, the 5D didn't had any nr options. As on the Nikon, i disabled them all.

Sony sensors have hardware noise reduction that cannot be disabled, tricks are already done in the raw


Reply

Please don't tell me i am stuck with this? Any new firmware addressing such issues?


Reply

I doubt any new firmware update will help, raw is the key for any serious work if you reject it I think nobody will care how much you like or not jpg. I think on this cameras jpg just a sketch only not final perfect output. To convert many RAW images in batch takes max 10 minutes on a PC and you have chance to improve a less good image. With jpg nearly impossible to fix sharpening problem etc. Better to think again raw vs jpg than look a new firmware update which is never come.


Reply

I offer you $100US for that crappy camera. In fact, I'll throw in an extra $50US towards S&H.





Twisted Evil Twisted Evil Twisted Evil Twisted Evil


Reply

Atilla: sadly RAW too clumsy for me.

Found out i had sharpness on level 2 after all Rolling Eyes . It's low value but nevertheless i have some space left.
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canoneos5dmarkii/page17.asp

Here i found photos at zero sharpness. Full crop jpeg. Smudge still there but kind of better. More visible on areas a bit out of focus:








Reply

Seems like jpeg can't win over raw. Yes, yes i was told so Smile. Here 2 of the best from selection of many.
Paintbrush effect is pretty obvious and annoying. Title might need correction.
I guess it's also the pseudo sharpening procedure to blame.

RAW


Jpeg zero sharpening


Reply

I turned everything off, contrast, sharp, I forget what else.
Its the amplifier that causes the noise right?
but I dont shoot jpeg Sad


Reply

Shoot raw.
One of the best things about the 5D MkII is that the AA filter is weaker compared to that of Nikon cameras, thus delivering less processed raw files. So use that feature to your advantage!


Reply

I have one simple rule: never let the camera create your JPEG's. It's like taking Polaroids: the end result will never be better than the original. In my workflow, working with RAWs is just as easy as working with JPEG's, only a little more time consuming because of the larger files.

I use the original 5D and I'm always amazed what I get out of its RAW files, especially at base ISO.


Reply

I can't help feeling sorry about strong jpeg NR / sharpening / warping effect on Canon. The thing is i use such effect too. But i don't want to be forced with it. Anyway crying about it doesn't make sense if there are so many positive sides of RAW which i am already starting to learn. I didn't know so much detail info is available in (over)bright and (over)dark parts.

Right now i need to buy new computer so i can come even close to the speed of processing i enjoyed so far with jpegs. I loved my computer system configuration. Used it unchanged nearly 5 years. It was really stable XP SP1 thus i resented changing it as long as i could Smile.


Reply

I don't shoot JPG, but if I did, I wouldn't have the high iso NR turned on, I'd run it through Noise Ninja instead.


Reply

DPP has a batch function to convert raws into JPeg.
It works well.