MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

On an absolute scale, how well aged is the Helios 44 Family?
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Hello, all!

Since buying my first DSLR, I have mostly just been looking at modern AF lenses. However now I need to buy a nice prime for portraits. Current offerings for my target fuckal length (like 50-85mmish range) seem to all have stark weaknesses. For example, Nikkor's (soon to be replaced) 50mm 1.8D is tack sharp for it's price but has distracting OOF elements. Sigma's 50mm 1.4 has pretty okay bokeh but has CA and sharpness and quality control issues.
Through my research, I recently came across some lenses from the old USSR-made Helios line. They look reasonably sharp and their OOF elements are different than anything I have ever seen before. That got me interested in buying a Helios 44-3, 44-6 or 44-7 for my Nikon D90. It looks like those models have the best IQ, even for today's standards.

So first off, I was wondering if infinity focus is possible with any of those models I listed. I saw that some people were able to mount the 44-3 to a Nikon body and have infinity focus by just fiddling with the rear element or something. Others I see have used a mount with a special adapter w/ an element, but it doesn't work well and degrades image quality.

I was also wondering how these lenses compare in image quality to modern-day equivalents, like the Tamron 60mm 2.8 (Well, that's a macro lens IIRC) From what I gather, they are well built but vary optically from copy to copy. I haven't been able to find measurements tests to see how they compare technically.

One last thing is I was wondering how usable they are, gauging them on an absolute scale, not like 'it's so good...for the price' or 'it's the 70-200... of it's day' . Will I miss shots from this that I could get with another lens?

Thanks a million!


Reply

Welcome!

As a Nikon owner look Nikkor lenses and medium format lenses and Tamron Adaptall-2, T2, T4,TX mount lenses, other 35mm lenses than Nikkor will not work on your camera with infinity support.
Nikon made great lenses and many of them inexpensive today. To use them perfectly on your camera look AI or AIS lenses earlier ones either can damage your camera or you can't rotate aperture ring on it.

From medium format lenses I do recommend Carl Zeiss Jena and Russian ones Kaleinar, Vega, Jupiter etc. If you need maximum sharpness with inexpensive lenses shoot in RAW and sharpen images in post process before convert them to jpeg. This is most inexpensive solution to get sharp , great looking images. Older lenses has character and you can get older top lenses on price of budget AF lenses and certainly older top lenses produce better IQ.

If you still want to use M42 lenses on Nikon you should know 135mm will be around 90mm and you can shoot from lens closest focus up to 3m.

Some of M42 lens adjustable for Nikon by technician some of them has Nikon and M42 mount both like Russian Kaleinar 100 or Tair-11

Tamron lenses are good performers , inexpensive and mount available to your camera.


Reply

Well, really I am just loking for something that has isolating but interesting bokeh like the Helios 44-3 appears to produce:

http://manualglass.com/archives/53


Reply

Hi Klaus

enthdegree hat folgendes geschrieben::

... Helios 44-3, 44-6 or 44-7 ...


Do you mean the 44M6 and 44M7 ?

Zitat:

So first off, I was wondering if infinity focus is possible with any of those models I listed.


Not with a simple mechanical adapter. The Nikon F register is 1 mm longer than the M42 register. My adapter has a thickness of 0.75 mm. So that's like using a ~ 2 mm extension ring - which removes infinity.

Zitat:
I saw that some people were able to mount the 44-3 to a Nikon body and have infinity focus by just fiddling with the rear element or something.


There's a guy on Manual Focus Forum called glimavitor who shows how you can modify a Helios 44M and achieve infinity focus on a Nikon body.

Zitat:
Others I see have used a mount with a special adapter w/ an element, but it doesn't work well and degrades image quality.


This problem has been discussed many times on this forum and elswhere. I don't think that the degradation is necessarily as bad as some people say. In fact many of them have never actually used such an adapter.

Zitat:
Will I miss shots from this that I could get with another lens?

I don't know - but I do. I find that AF is much quicker than my MF. But perhaps I'm lazy and don't practice enough. However there are two other problems. The first is aperture control. Nikon lenses, even the Ai series work with automatic aperture - even on digital SLRs (not everyone knows that !). The aperture is wide open for focussing and stops down to the working aperture when you press the shutter release button and before the shutter opens. For the Helios lenses you will have to stop down to the working aperture manually. Alternatively you will have to focus at the working aperture which is not always easy. The second problem is metering - there isn't any. The D90 won't even meter with Nikkor Ai lenses. For many situations these problems are not insurmountable. However you might miss some grab shots.


Reply

enthdegree hat folgendes geschrieben::

One last thing is I was wondering how usable they are, gauging them on an absolute scale, not like 'it's so good...for the price' or 'it's the 70-200... of it's day' . Will I miss shots from this that I could get with another lens?


I start with saying that most of the differences we talk about here between a lens and another, are really small differences. Most likely, 8 amateur photographers out of 10, and nearly 10 non-photographers out of 10, would not be able to tell the most part of the differences we often speak about.

Which, of course, does not mean that there are no differences... it only means that only trained photographers are able to tell them. If you want, it's the same as with wine: most people is not able to tell one red wine from another; some people are able to tell one red wine from another, but not really able to tell which one has to be considered the best wine, and why; and only a few connoisseurs can tell everything about a wine.

Will the Helios-44 let you take any pictures that you want? I think yes, it will. Of course it's not autofocus - but you know this already; and if you're like me, you probably also find that autofocus is more of a problem than a solution in many situations, compared to a good manual lens in the hands of a skilled photographer.
And as John pointed out, the aperture system (so called "preset") of the Helios-44 -at least of the first two versions- is such that many photographers of today are really in trouble with, because they're used to lenses with no aperture control, and with the Helios-44, they have not just one but two aperture controls. But like any other things, it's only a matter of getting used to.
So, like all manual instruments, the Helios-44 too requires some time for mastering it - once you do, your limit is your imagination (as they say in commercials).


Reply

sichko hat folgendes geschrieben::
Hi Klaus

enthdegree hat folgendes geschrieben::

... Helios 44-3, 44-6 or 44-7 ...


Do you mean the 44M6 and 44M7 ?

Zitat:

So first off, I was wondering if infinity focus is possible with any of those models I listed.


Not with a simple mechanical adapter. The Nikon F register is 1 mm longer than the M42 register. My adapter has a thickness of 0.75 mm. So that's like using a ~ 2 mm extension ring - which removes infinity.

Zitat:
I saw that some people were able to mount the 44-3 to a Nikon body and have infinity focus by just fiddling with the rear element or something.


There's a guy on Manual Focus Forum called glimavitor who shows how you can modify a Helios 44M and achieve infinity focus on a Nikon body.

Zitat:
Others I see have used a mount with a special adapter w/ an element, but it doesn't work well and degrades image quality.


This problem has been discussed many times on this forum and elswhere. I don't think that the degradation is necessarily as bad as some people say. In fact many of them have never actually used such an adapter.

Zitat:
Will I miss shots from this that I could get with another lens?

I don't know - but I do. I find that AF is much quicker than my MF. But perhaps I'm lazy and don't practice enough. However there are two other problems. The first is aperture control. Nikon lenses, even the Ai series work with automatic aperture - even on digital SLRs (not everyone knows that !). The aperture is wide open for focussing and stops down to the working aperture when you press the shutter release button and before the shutter opens. For the Helios lenses you will have to stop down to the working aperture manually. Alternatively you will have to focus at the working aperture which is not always easy. The second problem is metering - there isn't any. The D90 won't even meter with Nikkor Ai lenses. For many situations these problems are not insurmountable. However you might miss some grab shots.


Yeah, extra controls would be hard to learn but I am sure they would come at least partway with time. Yes, sorry I meant the 44M6 and 44M7.

Thanks for the explination on why it can't be mounted, now I understand. That makes me wonder though, from what you said, the lens has to be 2mm closer to the sensor so what would happen if you machined off that ~2mm of the focus ring so you could screw it further into the mount and thus have it sit closer to the sensor? Here is a picture http://i.imgur.com/qOwil.jpg

Either that or somehow modify the focus ring so that it could screw 'beyond infinity'

Razz Something tells me it is not that simple though...


Reply

I'm not sure about the 44-3, but the guy on the other forum has modified the 44-2 to give infinity on a Nikon body.


Reply

Very usable, if you persevere with it! The more that you use it, as you control it yourself, you will become a better photographer.

You will not zoom, but position yourself and will want to fully acquire knowledge of the depth of field at various focal points and aperture combinations. Akkk thew ckassic photographers estimated exposure by eye and compensated in processing. You will be less blase about shooting but more determined to take a picture? A positive experience, I assure you!