MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

The A850 - What should I do?
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

It's a very long story but the opportunity has has come along for me to purchase a new Sony A850. Not for any special price or anything just the money is there and if it is not spent in a few months it will be gone and I will not have the camera. I would rather not get into specifics if that is alright. It's nothing bad, just personal family matters.

It sounds like a no-brainer, yes?

But something is holding me back...For some reason I just have a sickening feeling because of the considerable investment into film made over the years. It's not like I can't keep using it, but will I? Probably only for b&w...Seems like a waste...

I guess I just need some forum members to give me advice. I know the right answer, which is to get the camera. But please, push me in a direction? Thanks!


Reply

Marc

I would love to see you shooting on digital. Why? Because you would post more pictures then Smile May I ask why you are heading for the a850 and not the 5D II? Mirror clearance?


Reply

Zitat:
May I ask why you are heading for the a850 and not the 5D II? Mirror clearance?


Yes. In body IS and mirror clearance are very appealing.

I do not need movies. I don't need extremes in ISO performance. I do not need higher FPS.

I really do believe the A850 is the body for me, if I were to get one at all.


Reply

What are the alternatives? For example, would a pro film/slide scanner be of some use?


Reply

Do you own a lot of Minolta/Sony A mount lens? If not, what lens do you plan to use with the A850? There are many lens which you will not be able to use on a Sony DSLR. I am using A700, so I know the pain.

To maximise usage of in body stabilization, you will need to use AF lens. In theory, chip adapter should also allow body stabilization but I have never tested it since most of my adapters are non chip. Top of the range AF lens in Sony and Minolta includes Sony Zeiss and Sony/Minolta G lens. Yes, Sony Zeiss are all AF lens.


Reply

I made the step in spring 2006. Having some years of little activity in photography I wanted to follow a growing up puppy in digital. Started to try with P&S, but they were far too slow then. Getting some pics of tailpoints and sleeping dogs, that was it. Purchased KM5D helped me to take pics as wanted.
But my load of MC/MD lenses stayed with me and I still like to use them on my filmbodies, however not very frequently. Adapter with glass for the AF mount is no go for me, but macro with glassless adapter is fine (I have 50mm and 100mm macro Rokkors).
On the KM5D I use several M42 lenses for MF. I cannot permit myself Zeiss and Leitz lenses now, so that is not the point for me - but some can be converted.
May be a moment comes that I buy a Sony Nex with adapter for the MC/DC lenses ro use them digital. But I still like working with film, so its not urgent for me.


Reply

I solely use m42 lenses. I will no doubt invest into a few modern minolta/sony lenses but I have yet to do the research to say for sure.

My film scanner currently is the v700. It is by no means professional, but it is certainly acceptable.

I guess the alternative is to buy some really expensive glass. Maybe a few from the Zeiss ZS line...


Reply

I think you should go for the a850 then Smile Whilst people will generally say "buy decent glass first", I'm sure your Russians would be fine on the Sony. Whilst some Zeiss glass would be very nice, you could always buy later in Contax mount and use Leitax adapters to fit the Sony to bring the cost down...


Reply

Well, if you want to do digital with full-frame sensor to use with M42, then you have not much choice left:
- Sony 850 or 900 (main difference being the 100% viewfinder)
- Canon 5D2 or 1Ds3
- Leica M9 Wink

or get a used 5D1 + expensive glass Very Happy


Reply

i had a sony and loved it, esp IS, so i think sony is a great choice, and you can use m42, contax and others that will keep you happy for a long time.

however, i would echo the above comment and strongly suggest considering canon 5dmk1, which i have as well. it is heavy enough where i never miss IS of sony, it is tremendous in low light, there is almost no lens you cannot use on it and it is probably less than half the cost of the sony 850! it doesnt have movies, so youre not paying for something you wont use, and you can either save the extra $1000 or buy a planar 85/1.4 and still have $250-300 left over! and btw, i have many russian lenses in m42 and i absolutely love them on the 5d.

point being, IS may not be worth the extra $1000 from sony to canon, especially when you are coming from the film world where you are used to no IS, and honestly that is mostly the only advantage of 850 over 5d.

you will not regret buying the sony i am sure, but i am equally sure you will not regret buying the canon!

good luck!


Reply

The original 5D does not have the same mirror clearance issues as the Mark II?


Reply

themoleman342 hat folgendes geschrieben::
The original 5D does not have the same mirror clearance issues as the Mark II?

My understanding: yes, there is an issue, but not the same as with 5D2.


Reply

ylyad hat folgendes geschrieben::
themoleman342 hat folgendes geschrieben::
The original 5D does not have the same mirror clearance issues as the Mark II?

My understanding: yes, there is an issue, but not the same as with 5D2.


My understanding is that the 5D II is generally better as you can use lenses with liveview...


Reply

By the way, A850/A900 does not have movie mode either. The price different of used 5D Mk1 and used A850 should be in the range of $500. Spec of A850 should be higher compared to 5D Mk1 if this is something of importance.

At current there are only few Sony zeiss lens. FF: 16-35/2.8. 24-70/2.8, 24/2.8, 85/1.4, 135/1.8 and cropped 16-80/3.5-4.5.


Reply

on the 5d mirror clearance, yes its an issue for a VERY LIMITED subset of lenses, clearly documented on this forum. i have used well over 50-60 different lenses, from inexpesive russian to zeiss planars and have never had an issue.

mark if theres a specific lens youre concerned about im sure the answer is here, but this lens clearance issue is WAY overblown imho, unless you already have in your possession a favorite lens you dont want to do without that you know will have this problem. i does not appear to me, given your well known love of russiam m42s, that this is the case. is there a specific lens(es) you have in mind!

as for price difference, i did a quick search and couldnt find an a850 for less than $1900, while i bought my 5d 18 months ago for $950, in great shape.


Reply

I guess I view the mirror clearance issue as important because if I were to take this step, I'd want ALL my lenses to be compatible. It truly is some sort of obsessive compulsion that I've taken on. Incompatibility occurs even between native m42 film bodies and native m42 lenses and it REALLY bothers me to be limited in such a way. So you may laugh, but from what I've read the 5d has issues with the helios, the mir, some takumars. There are workarounds for sure. It's just that I don't even want to think about it. I want to attach a lens and shoot, not get bogged down with "Oh, I have to stay away from focusing to infinity with this lens." Forgive me if this is irrational. In many ways, I know it is since the money I would save could go to supremely 'better' lenses than what I have but I've collected for very specific things for years. It's hard to make any sacrifice.

I also really welcome the upgrade in image quality. I'm sure everyone has their opinions and will likely disagree but I don't see the 12mps of the 5d being a supreme upgrade from my film setup. For convenience sake (being able to switch iso, no scanning time, ect) it would be night and day. But while shooting a good 100 speed film, I think I get somewhere close to the same quality. And I much prefer film's "feeling" vs. digital even if it's not a quantifiable observation.


Zuletzt bearbeitet von themoleman342 am Di Apr 12, 2011 8:02 pm, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

M, totally get it, and frankly it can make me a bit daft when i ask for help to go left and people insist on giving me directions to the right!

having said that, i have helios 44 and 44-n, mir 20 and 35, jupiter 80 and taks 50/1.4, 35/2.8 and 135, with no problem at all on 5d. i too would go nuts with the limitations you describe, or having to alter my lenses to fit a cam--i just have never had these issues with the 5d.

anyway, as i said, you wont regret a850 purchase! let us know when you get it!
tony


Reply

It's been ordered! Along with a few accessories *cough vertical grip cough*... Rolling Eyes

I thank you gentlemen greatly. Tony, I really do appreciate the explanation of alternatives you presented. It helped to clarify why I wanted the a850.

~Marc


Reply

If I may interject (a bit late)...

I spend some little time considering supplemental cameras. Not upgrades to my Pentax K20D, just MORE. The two main objects of my lust are a Sony NEX and/or A850. The NEX, for all the LBA possibilities. The A850, for FF. What stops me is, NO MONEY! If I sell my other house [ http://bisbee.klaxo.net ] or enough excess lenses, I might be able to afford a NEX. But I won't have enough for an A850 system unless I receive another inheritance, and I don't really want any more relatives to die soon. So, these remain fantasies.

I haven't really considered any Canon FF system because 1) I read of Canon's mirror problems, 2) I really don't mind being non-Canikonian, and 3) my bro-in-law would probably give me some of his extra Alpha lenses. (He has already offered me his old Bronica system but I haven't room for it.) So I needn't soul-search over FF possibilities. I know what I want. I just can't have it. Yet. I am so tired of being patient... Confused