MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

25mm& 50mm comparison Zeiss CY vs Zeiss cine lenses
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Today I had some time off and managed to shoot some comparison shots with my Eos 7D equipped with Zeiss CY lenses vs a modified 7D which allows to use cine PL mount lenses.
Both cameras shooting Raw,
both focused on a siemens star chart with 10x magnify help


Raw shooting full resolution 18MP,
same stop,
same shutter,
same post processing

and both cameras on tripods


the candidates:

A: 2.8/25mm Zeiss CY MM Version vs 1.2/ 25 Zeiss HS vs 1.9/24mm Ultra Prime vs a 1.8/25mm Red Pro Prime

B: 1.4/50mm Zeiss CY MM Version vs 1.2/ 50 Zeiss HS vs 1.9/50mm Ultra Prime vs a 1.8/50mm Red Pro Prime


Of course it is not a scientific test, (I shot a shelf) and it is somehow unfair to compare them as the cine lenses are newer and cost approx x10-20 more than the CY.

But if you always wanted to know how big the differences are, please let me know and I will post some results later.










Zuletzt bearbeitet von agent_cooper am Mo März 21, 2011 7:35 pm, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

Wow! What a fascinating set of gear!

Of course we are interested in the differences. Wink

But once you have shot the Siemens Star, I would be very interested in how those lenses perform in "real" photographic situations, indoors and outdoors.


Reply

LucisPictor hat folgendes geschrieben::
Wow! What a fascinating set of gear!

Of course we are interested in the differences. Wink

But once you have shot the Siemens Star, I would be very interested in how those lenses perform in "real" photographic situations, indoors and outdoors.


+1 Very Happy


Reply

you should compare a 25mm on FF vs a 15mm on crop
and a 50mm on FF vs a 30mm on crop


Reply

poilu hat folgendes geschrieben::
you should compare a 25mm on FF vs a 15mm on crop
and a 50mm on FF vs a 30mm on crop


Sorry, I completely disagree with you. This way it would be the same angle of view but a completely different distortion and Space feeling. Keep in mind Cinema cameras are more APS than FF. 35mm Cinema lenses do NOT cover FF!


Reply

sorry agent_cooper, I misread and thought it was a about 5DII vs 7D


Reply

finally I found the time to evaluate the test.

one regular Eos 7D on tripod, beside a modified 7D with PL Mount.

same stop, same shutter, shooting raw no sharpening, no special PP.

the subject ca 3,50m distance:

100% crops






center ZEISS CY 25mm/2.8_2.8





center Zeiss HS 25mm/1.4_2.8





center Ultra Prime Prime 24mm/1.9_2.8





center RED Pro Prime 25mm/1.8_2.8






center bottom ZEISS CY 25mm/2.8_2.8






center bottom Zeiss HS 25mm/1.4_2.8





center bottom Ultra Prime Prime 24mm/1.9_2.8





center bottom RED Pro Prime 25mm/1.8_2.8



Reply

50mm


center ZEISS CY 50mm/1.4_2.0






center Zeiss HS 50mm/1.4_2.0






center RED Pro Prime 50mm/1.8_2.0






right ZEISS CY 50mm/1.4_2.0







right Zeiss HS 50mm/1.4_2.0





right RED Pro Prime 50mm/1.8_2.0



Reply

Astonishingly disappointing I would dare to say! Certainly not my
experience with Zeiss lenses, but I never tested cine lenses
(except my Kinoptiks - and I would bet they beat that).


Reply

I'm sorry that you have such a poor copy of the Distagon 25mm.
You have been very unlucky, even my AE copy of the lens (which I sold years ago) gave a lot better results wide open than what you are showing here.


Reply

Yes indeed. I had the new 25mm Z series and my friend and
I did some testing years ago on teh optical bench also using
a Siemens star, and indeed found that it resolved close to 400lpm.


Reply

yes indeed, the 25 was a bad copy. Since this test I bought another one with serial number #81... Shocked Laughing which performs much better in terms of flare and sharpness. But CA remains the same.

And thats the point: The test cleary shows the abundance of CA with my Zeiss CY glas. Since I used all lenses with a Eos sensor it proves the problem is not due sensor bloom because all other lenses (HS, Ultra Prime, Red Prime) perform better.