MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Buying new camera Pentax K-x or Canon T1i
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Hi all

Im looking to grab a new camera and have narrowed it down to either the Pentax k-x or the Canon T1i. as they both are able to shoot video, and high ISO for low light/indoor shots ( I think the T1i does 6400 and the K-X does 12800)

the Pentax has IS in the camera body and is 510 shipped
the T1i has no IS and its 729 shipped

Has anyone tried the k-x with old MF lenses? my understanding is that the Pentax K lenses should slot right on, and Pentax makes a M42> K adapter , is that right?

re: T1i, I have a rebel XT now and I only have 3 lenses for it, kit 18-55 , 50mm F1.8 II , and a 70-200 F4L which Ill probably sell as its too heavy to lug around while chasing my 2 little kids.

oh, the K-X also comes in a cool red or white colour Smile


any comments/suggestions/tips are welcome

cheers


Reply

Hi!

The Pentax is said to do the better low light/high Iso! It's more conviniet from the start with manual lenses as it has focus confirmation without the need of an electronic adapter!

On the other hand you have some nice glas for the canon!

But seriously, I wouldn't change a Rebel for a Rebel! Get something 40D upwards when staying with Canon! With a new Rebel, the viewfinder is still small, the body is still crap and the cam is still slow!

The Pentax K-x may not be faster or handling better though!

If you want to step up from your Rebel and change system, consider to save more money and go for a Pentax K-x, Olympus E-30, Nikon D300/s or Sony A850!

cheers,

Karhallarn


Reply

Pentax is better for pentax glass as you can use some of the auto metering features. However, not much besides just Pentax mount (k or m42) will fit on a pentax.

Canon has a very flexible mount and can mount Nikon, Olympus, Pentax M42, Contax/Yashica, Leica R to name a few.

Pure image quality is very close on these cameras. The Kx might win by a hair for noise handling, but the t1i has more resolution. I don't think you would be dissatisfied with either camera. I would just pick based on how each camera feels in your hand to use. And of course if you want some auto-metering and AF confirm options with Pentax glass or the ability to use a wider variety of lens mounts on Canon.


Reply

If you're an aficionado of vintage lenses, then your choice is the Canon as it allows more lenses to be adapted without a glass element. Also, I know you listed the Canon t1i as one of the cams you're interested in but you might want to look into the t2i for its advanced video functions so you can have a camera AND a kick ass camcorder as well. This is a video I shot with the cam using a Helios 44M.....

http://vimeo.com/10942299

Best of luck with the new camera purchase!


Reply

The K-x will certainly be able to accept any K mount, K-AF and K-AF2 lens from any number of manufacturers. There is no mechanical restriction and all Pentax dslr camera allow for some exposure metering with manual focus, K mount lenses.
Pentax has used the bayonet style, K mount on their camera systems since 1975. Meaning that with absolutely no adaptors or modification, you have 35 years of lens choices from countless suitable manufacturers. (But please not Ricoh) The much older M42 screw mount lenses obviously need some adaptation to K mount bodies.
Can someone help me with a little knowledge? Today's digital Canons like the T2i are EF mount and I assume that this system will accept older manual focus lenses as well. But can Canon boast about accepting lenses without adaptations made 35 years ago? I am not picking a fight, I merely hope to educate myself as well.
Aside from electronic connections for metering, how far back into lens stock can a T2i user go? When did Canon start using mechanical connections on lens and camera mounts that are the same as today's digital slr cameras?
I think both cameras make fantastic "entry level" cameras. (It is amazing how "entry level cameras have advanced in many ways) Price points are one way of looking at the two perhaps. The Pentax costs a little less and most likely over the life of the camera. Canon sells a lot of stuff but keeps their prices inflated I think.
I sometimes really lust for a dslr in red or blue. I could not give a damn what other people think about the colors. That K-x seems like a great little camera with some super features and I could get it in red, white or blue? Very nice!


Reply

Since many years concerning digital I´m a Canon boy.

Nevertheless I bought last year a Pentax K200D. The only reason to do this was the integrated IS.

I bought a Pentax to M42 adapter and all my M42 (CZJ, Takumare etc) lenses now have the IS.

I´m not sure whether the K-x own this feature too. The K200D has the internal light if the focus is correct. No chip adapter etc.

Perfect.


Wink


Reply

I beg to differ about Canon... I had a 5D (granted, a FF camera) and I had far too many problems to mount my lenses without mirror problems. At least 50% of my lenses had problems, so I quickly ditched the system. A FF Pentax is my dream camera Smile

Any M42 lens will fit the Pentax without any problem.


Reply

Not an easy choice - if you want to use a variety of MF lens mountings, Canon's probably the one, but I have an older Pentax (K10D) and for me the IS is worth its weight in gold. It works well, and it works with any lens you hang on the body.


Reply

Thanks for the hints and tips, I will still have the Rebel XT to use the manual lenses on , and I like the idea of the K-X having IS on the body along with its excellent low light ISO ability .

I believe my XT has ISO 1600 but its very nosiy at that setting , even in RAW, so going to 12800 would be 3 stops better, and I think Pentax says the IS is good for 4 ish ( allegedly!)

Im still awaiting an email from a pal in Japan, if I get the K-X I may as well get one of the multicolouredones.....


Reply

Not sure why more people in this situation don't consider the A900 or as Karhallarn mentioned, the A850 as well. FF, sensor based shake reduction and registration 1mm shorter than Pentax, so more lenses technically can be adapted.

While it is true that there is no on-board facility to dial in focal length of a lens with a passive adapter, I have purchased a chipped adapter for each of my lenses that I use regularly enough to justify it and leave them on each lens. On the plus side, I just mount the lens and shoot like any other lens, no input required.

Lastly, the factory viewfinder & screen destroys the K20D + Katzeye I used to use for manual shooting. Not sure how the 5D stand-up to the A900 in this regard though.

Kelly.


Reply

Well the reason I didnt consider the A900 was because it was 5x the price of the K-X and 4x the price of the T1i!

One of the reasons I am leaning towards the K-X was to save 300 bucks, and your suggestions are 2500 and 1999 Smile


Reply

Spotmatic hat folgendes geschrieben::
I beg to differ about Canon... I had a 5D (granted, a FF camera) and I had far too many problems to mount my lenses without mirror problems. At least 50% of my lenses had problems, so I quickly ditched the system. A FF Pentax is my dream camera Smile

Any M42 lens will fit the Pentax without any problem.


But if you switched to Pentax, you switched to an APS sensor. If you use APS Canon cameras, you have no problems with mirror inteference, either.


Reply

Buttermilk Pancakes hat folgendes geschrieben::
Pentax has used the bayonet style, K mount on their camera systems since 1975. Meaning that with absolutely no adaptors or modification, you have 35 years of lens choices from countless suitable manufacturers. (But please not Ricoh)


For what it is worth, aside from the Ricohs, there are other lenses which won't work without modification on the Pentax DLSRs. I found this out when I tried to mount a Vivitar telephoto on my mother's K100D.


More information:
http://www.robertstech.com/flange.htm
http://photo.net/pentax-camera-forum/00ODF0

That being said, I think that only a very small number of lenses fit into this category... and the modifications to fix the problems are not very difficult. It certainly wouldn't scare me away from Pentax DLSRs, but it is something to be aware of. Wink


Reply

dude163 hat folgendes geschrieben::
Well the reason I didnt consider the A900 was because it was 5x the price of the K-X and 4x the price of the T1i!

One of the reasons I am leaning towards the K-X was to save 300 bucks, and your suggestions are 2500 and 1999 Smile


Ah yes - there is the price, buying of individual chipped adapters is $50 each too, worth factoring in.

Your budget may make the little devil I'll try to put on your shoulder moot, but I would leave you with the notion that once you've been spoiled by the amenities on offer down this path, it's easier to justify the expenditure, and harder to consider anything less. I sold a lot initially to generate the funds and have been filling in the holes since, but I haven't regretted it.

Best of luck with your choice!


K.


Reply

Before I go into my opinion on this, I must state that I don't have experience with either camera or camera brand. What I think I know comes from reading at various forums. I too have been considering a Pentax. In fact, I considered one before purchasing my Sony, but chose the Sony because I wanted to use the older Minolta AF lenses which are fully functional on the Sony - and are very good relatively inexpensive glass. I also wanted to use my old Rokkors, but that hasn't worked out as well.

From what I have learned/heard, Pentax seems to have better support for manual lenses. Possibly even a factor in their development efforts. I believe in-camera stabilization is a big bonus, especially since it also works for manual lenses. The fact that PK mounts fit directly is further bonus.

The downside of Pentax is that there is no sign that FF is in the future. They are also far from market leading and may be less stable long term.

Another thought to ponder might be a a dual approach, since you already have the Canon and some glass which is fully functional. Is there that much to gain from selling it and replicating on Pentax? I've been considering keeping my Sony so I can continue using the Minolta lenses that I like so much, and having the Pentax for manual lens use. I would buy a Pentax body only and I already have most of the manual lenses I want.


Reply

Looks like a white K-X might show up here for my birthday my wife said ")


thanks for the tips and assistance gang


Reply

Good deal, Dude. I'd like to hear from you as you begin to get experience with the camera. I'm starting to itch for that K-x. I'm primarily interested for manual lens use.

There were good suggestions made in this thread, but I do understand the cost issue. While I'd love to have a Sony 900 or 850, one can't consider them at the same time as a K-x. The cameras we consider are usually driven first by affordability, then feature performance.


Reply

I wanted to respond to the previous poster who asked about using Canon Manual focus lenses on Canon auto-focus bodies. Canon's old manual focus mounts (everything since they went to bayonet) had the at-one-time advantage of being bigger than everybody elses. Unfortunately that makes it IMPOSSIBLE to adapt them to Canon's present mount and have anything close to infinity focus. While many other manual focus lenses can be adapted to Canon auto-focus bodies, Canons cannot.

My own lens collection is all M42, and I'm not going to spend big bucks to replace it. In my opinon image stabilization is the MOST SIGNIFICANT quality improvement in 35mm photography since lenses became multi-coated. There were lots of little handling and speed improvements - internal light meters got 'smarter' (note I didn't use the word 'better'). Electronic controlled vertical metal shutters got a little faster and held their accuracy better. But, really nothing substantially improved image quality of handheld 35mm shooting until image stabilization. Now for me to be able to buy a internally stabilized body, that will take my 50 year old lenses and bring them into the 21st Century is just MIND BLOWING!.

I am not completely sure how the superiority that good prime lenses had over wide range zooms when shooting kodachrome (at medium aperture on a tripod) is going to translate into present (affordable) digital resolution, but it can't hurt. Since L glass lenses at $1,600 each aren't in my budget, I think the sharpness, high contrast and lack of distortion of some of my old lenses should work just fine on a new Pentax body. And I am not going to miss having to wait for the damn camera to lock the focus on the wrong thing, or average the autoexposure wrong on a subject in constant lighting where a hand held incident light meter (or guess and check) would do just fine.

I can hardly wait to see the results of moderate ISO available light stabilized shooting with a 50mm f1.4 as a 75mm equivalent.

Doug H.


Reply

I got a white K-X (18-55 kit lens) 731 Canadian taxes included

Blacks is a chain of stores in canada and they have the K-X on sale for 629 and they have a promo where you trade in an old digital camera ( In my case an old Kodak P&S KX3200 2 megapixel!) to get 100 off , so the K-X was 529, and i grabbed their other deal:

A Lowepro bag, lenspen, 4GB class 6 SD card , 100 free prints, and a 3 year warranty for 99bucks!

the downside is: I have to wait a week or so for the camera to show up, they only had the black ones in store


Reply

dude163 hat folgendes geschrieben::
I got a white K-X (18-55 kit lens) 731 Canadian taxes included

Blacks is a chain of stores in canada and they have the K-X on sale for 629 and they have a promo where you trade in an old digital camera ( In my case an old Kodak P&S KX3200 2 megapixel!) to get 100 off , so the K-X was 529, and i grabbed their other deal:

A Lowepro bag, lenspen, 4GB class 6 SD card , 100 free prints, and a 3 year warranty for 99bucks!

the downside is: I have to wait a week or so for the camera to show up, they only had the black ones in store


I hope you enjoy the camera, I have a K200D that works very well with manual focus lenses. From what I have seen on the Pentax forums the K-x should do as well with the advantage of much better high ISO performance.

Here are a few images from M42 lenses, first is a Pentacon MC 50 f1.8, second and third are from a SMC Takumar 50 f1.4:






Reply

dude that's a great deal, congratulations!

if using M42 glass, Pentax, IMO, is the best system:

use of simple mechanical adapter making the lens fit flush on the body,
good metering ( in A mode or M mode pressing the 'green button', which one works better depends on model )
image stabilisation
double focus confirmation
good viewfinders
- and that comes in nicely designed bodies with good handling, mostly cheaper and smaller ( which I like, not everybody may ) than those of competitors.

Canon has the, for some, decisive advantage of accepting a larger variety of lenses! Nikon, Olympus, Leica and Zeiss Bajonett lenses also 'can' be used on Pentax, Nikon mostly streight without modification but fitting not perfectly well, OM lenses need filing on the bayonett. Leica and Zeiss lenses need adaptation of the lens, the Leitax adapter may cost up to 100 USD though, but on the other hand on Pentax you won't need to buy any adapters which, in the case of Canon, needing one for each Bayonett, will add in costs too. Canon / Sony of course had FF cameras which could be the reason to chose those.

I have been using M42 lenses on Pentax *istDs and now K-x with great satisfaction, see: http://www.flickr.com/photos/kuuan/collections/72157604973031858/

best greetings


Reply

I have been using the K-x for a month now (and previously the K100D for two+ years). The K-x is a perfectly fine camera for MF M42 lenses, at least as good as the K100D, and does not even require the setting changes one had to do for the K100d/K10D.

Its definitely a poor mans MF DSLR; the lenses one misses out on are (though probably the worlds finest) generally quite expensive ones.

And IS is indeed a magic feature.