MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Is the Canon 5D insensitive to certain colors?
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

In my garden, a few wild flowers are growing next to a rose bush. What strikes me is that the flower in particular comes out as almost white when I take a photo of it with the 5D. The flower should have a strong violet (?) color. Is the sensor or the AA filter responsible for this?



The color is not there either when shot with my Pentax K20D.



Zuletzt bearbeitet von Spotmatic am Fr Jun 12, 2009 12:41 pm, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

could it be because fo a bit overexposure in this picture?

did you already try to underexposure, for better contrast on the violett flower? that should also effect color contrast, or not?


Reply

The first one does look overexposed but the second one looks as if it was shot through a polariser. Where are all the reflected highlights from the leaves?

Maybe you need both to adjust the exposure and use a polariser.


Reply

Compare the two roses at the middle bottom. The Canon shot is obviously overexposed (or the other one underexposed - it depends on what was the light situation)


Reply

OK, maybe I did not expose the 5D shot too well... But I have made various pictures and the color of the flower *never* comes close to reality. Not even when I underexpose (a lot) intentionally. The flower should have a strong color but no matter what I do, I cannot capture it. Instead, the "veins" of the leaves come out exceptionally well, but my eyes cannot see them that strong as shown here. There's really a lot of color missing.

Maybe Klaus can tell us more?


Reply

Spotmatic hat folgendes geschrieben::
OK, maybe I did not expose the 5D shot too well... But I have made various pictures and the color of the flower *never* comes close to reality. Not even when I underexpose (a lot) intentionally. The flower should have a strong color but no matter what I do, I cannot capture it. Instead, the "veins" of the leaves come out exceptionally well, but my eyes cannot see them that strong as shown here. There's really a lot of color missing.

Maybe Klaus can tell us more?


Try changing the 5D picture mode from "Standard" to "Neutral" or "Faithful".


Reply

Orio hat folgendes geschrieben::

Try changing the 5D picture mode from "Standard" to "Neutral" or "Faithful".


Do those settings matter to RAW images???


Reply

The flower looks like a Geranium cultivar, possibly this one...



I find it very difficult to capture these without blowing the highlights. In strong sunlight the pigments seem to bleach very easily


Reply

Spotmatic hat folgendes geschrieben::
Orio hat folgendes geschrieben::

Try changing the 5D picture mode from "Standard" to "Neutral" or "Faithful".


Do those settings matter to RAW images???


They matter when you convert out of RAW (you can try them all in the raw converter). And you might do better selecting "landscape". The difference between the results from these settings is quite dramatic.

But I still don't understand why the leaves are reflective in one shot and not in the other. Reflectivity is nothing to do with the camera.

And while I think of it, the Pentax shot has a warmer WB.

With a few adjustments there is this (and your RAW file would obviously be able to offer much more)


Zuletzt bearbeitet von PaulC am Fr Jun 12, 2009 1:56 pm, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

PaulC hat folgendes geschrieben::

But I still don't understand why the leaves are reflective in one shot and not in the other. Reflectivity is nothing to do with the camera..


I think it's because of the angle.
The Pentax shot was taken from a more perpendicular angle, therefore the angle of view did not match the angle of reflection anymore (or otherwise said the angle of view was at a degree smaller than 90° to the angle of incidence).


Reply

sichko hat folgendes geschrieben::
The flower looks like a Geranium cultivar, possibly this one...



I find it very difficult to capture these without blowing the highlights. In strong sunlight the pigments seem to bleach very easily

Ditto here. Both on the 10D and the K10D that particular shade of flower is hard to get just right, tending to go too white and lose detail.


Reply

After a good thought I think that the flower is reflecting IR light, which is invisible for human eyes. I know that I can take a photo of the IR light my TV remote emits, could it be that this is the explanation for this phenomenon? Or is it UV light that is responsible for my problems? I'll try to capture the same scene with an UV filter tomorrow. I'll have to find one first though; I'm used to throwing them away because I do not like to use filters on my lenses Wink

This is wat I'm seeing:



And this is what my K20D and 5D record:





Reply

I'm not sure that it will help .... but here's an attempt

#1 This one was underexposed by ~1/3 stop and corrected in RAW conversion. It's not great - missed focus - but it sets a baseline



#2 The next was taken seconds after #1 and is overexposed by ~ 1stop. I'm not sure what happened - perhaps the sun came out from behind a cloud or maybe (more likely) I overcorrected the error in #1. Simple RAW conversion - no exposure correction.



#3 Same shot as #2 except that exposure was adjusted in RAW conversion. The bright highlights are not "blown" in the sense that they are clipped but they ruin the pic.



Finally a 4th example. This is a different species and shows that the pattern (or at least the intensity) of pigmentation can vary in different geraniums.



I think that your example and the Nova Scotia pic are different geraniums.

I note your comment about UV filters. For some reason I stopped using them some time ago. Perhaps now is the time to start again.

(For interest - you can do a Google search and see what others achieve with these flowers - the 1st flower (#s 1-3) is Geranium (x) oxonianum 'Claridge Druce'. The second is Geranium sanguineum).


Reply

Bjorn Rorslett's investigation http://www.naturfotograf.com/UV_IR_rev07.html suggests that UV filters are likely to be of little or no use on Canon cameras, but it will be interesting to see if they make a difference. I still reckon a polariser to kill reflections would probably be more effective.

Perhaps our friend Dr Klaus schmitt, who seems to be leading expert on UV photography, can tell us some more about whether UV has any effect on the output of the 5D..