MFlenses - Ein neues Leben im digitalen Zeitalter
MFLenses 2026

Forum für Manual-Fokus-Objektive

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.

Entdecke die Welt der Vintage-Objektive mit Reparaturnotizen, echten Testfotos und detaillierten Archiv-Themen voller Bilder.
Spotlight

Hervorgehobene Partnerplatzierung auf der Forum-Startseite.

Crazy idea? "Degrading" from K10D to istDs
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  


Reply

Hi colleagues:

I've received an interesting offer to acquire a Pentax istDs. The camera is in very good shape and the price is interesting.

I love the K10D but I think it's overkill for me. I love photography but I must accept I'm not an outstanding photographer. So a simpler camera can be enough for me. For instance, I feel I don't need the 10Mpixels on the K10D, 6Mpx are enough for me. I don't use to print pictures and most of them (if not all) are going to be viewed on a PC screen.

Neither I need the stabilization in the body. Luckyly I've got an steady hand that allow me to take successfully pictures even at low speeds (sometimes 1/10 s). And I can use the tripod anyway.

On the other hand, the key feature that is the light measuring for all the lenses, seem to be better on the istDs that on the K10D.

So I'm navigating in a sea of doubts. Selling the K10D could give me a positive balance of 200€ that could contribute to buy a better scanner for film...

In example, I still keep the Canon 350D and I'm happy with it. I've learned to know it's limits, and we live happy together. I don't feel the need of a 50D or a 5D for what I use to do. I miss the sensor cleaning, (but not too much, up to know the big air pear has been enough to keep the dust off the sensor. A monthly blow keeps the dust under control).

I'd appreciate very much your comments/opinions on this. Is really the istDs better than the K10D with MFLenses?. Would you do that in my case?.
Thanks in advance!.

Jes.


Reply

I don't know either of your camera, I have Olympus E-1 and Olympus E-300
E-300 is a great camera for me, but I love to use E-1 more E-1 provide better images than E-300. If possible shoot with 1stDs and if you think you will not see significant difference , don't hesitate sell your K10D.


Reply

Attila hat folgendes geschrieben::
I don't know either of your camera, I have Olympus E-1 and Olympus E-300
E-300 is a great camera for me, but I love to use E-1 more E-1 provide better images than E-300. If possible shoot with 1stDs and if you think you will not see significant difference , don't hesitate sell your K10D.


The seller is a workmate and he's confident enough with me that will lend me the camera for a week, so I can try the MF lenses on it and compare to the K10D measuring... I't will be a hard and busy week!.

Jes.


Reply

Good luck mate! I expect 1stDs will work for you!


Reply

My opinion, and this is only an opinion - If you think the ist fits you better, then by all means do the switch... But I do think you should try it for a week to asses if the lack of image stabilization / the difference in metering does any noticeable difference to you or your pictures Smile I think you'll find the slightly lower weight of the ist is something that makes a big positive difference too! (But I actually thought that the K10D had better metering with manual K-mount lenses than the istDs has...??)

I have access to several 1DsIII's, D3's and P45's and lots of REALLY sweet glass through my work (I'm a pre-press engineer, we have a small but very capable studio also), and we're actually encouraged to use them for personal means... But almost all of my "recreation" photography is done with the "lowly" 6MP Nikon D40 and legacy or converted older glass. No metering, no AF. I'm about to buy the D700 as an X-mas gift for myself, but that is mainly because I'm preparing for the fact that the D40 may die from old age soon. And I'm lusting for difference in the full-frame and better metering capability... (The D40 cannot meter at all with older lenses)


PS - I'm actually very happy to see that someone dares to say that they prioritize their own need and ergonomics in stead of always hunting for the highest MP figures and extreme ISO's... For me this only means that you care more about your pictures than your equipment. And to openly say so in this day and time is.... Kudos! Hope it works out for the best. DS


Reply

I say try it and see.
Don't worry about the megapix game.
When I got the RD 1 I was first concerned with it's relatively low 6.3 MP.
But now it is my favorite Digital camera and I hope she never dies.
The type of shots I use it for will likely never be printed large so the lower res is fine.
You are smart to consider your uses and needs. I would add however that the K10D is maybe a better processor regardless of pixel count.
Clean images at higher ISO's with better dynamic range seem to be what you are most at risk of losing by moving down.


Reply

the_Suede hat folgendes geschrieben::
I'm actually very happy to see that someone dares to say that they prioritize their own need and ergonomics in stead of always hunting for the highest MP figures and extreme ISO's... For me this only means that you care more about your pictures than your equipment. And to openly say so in this day and time is.... Kudos! Hope it works out for the best. DS

Me2. A Spottie with a 6Mp digital back would be ideal! Smile


Reply

Hi, Jes!
Have fun testing the differences.
For me, it would be the K10D. Not because of my photographic talent (this would served well with an *istD), no because of the bigger size, the heavier weight, the stabilizer and the weather sealing.
If I were to buy a Pentax DSLR, it would be a K10D or a K20D.

Once I got to know the heft and feel of my 40D, I do not want to go back to a small cam. Wink My 2c.
After I was playing around with the Nikon D90, I got the D60 yesterday. It just feels like a toy...


Reply

Jes hat folgendes geschrieben::
So a simpler camera can be enough for me

you could also stay with only one dslr. You already have your GX100 as backup


Reply

Carsten did you buy a Nikon? Shocked


Reply

Jes, a K10D is in my future plans... but unfortunately not now Sad


Reply

poilu hat folgendes geschrieben::
Jes hat folgendes geschrieben::
So a simpler camera can be enough for me

you could also stay with only one dslr. You already have your GX100 as backup


Good point!

Why have Pentax at all if not for the Shake Reduction? Having steady hands just means that you will get more out of the SR.


Reply

Riku hat folgendes geschrieben::
poilu hat folgendes geschrieben::
Jes hat folgendes geschrieben::
So a simpler camera can be enough for me

you could also stay with only one dslr. You already have your GX100 as backup


Good point!

Why have Pentax at all if not for the Shake Reduction? Having steady hands just means that you will get more out of the SR.


Whoa, I didn't know you had the GX100 Jes...

Perhaps just keep that GX100 (what a BEAUTY), and scrap the DSLR venue. Shocked

Why do I say that? Well, because I had the Pentax K110D for a few months, and it was a wonderful camera.

But I REALLY thought it out, and with the "lowly" 6MP Minolta A-1 for my backup, I felt that it was completely adequate for my needs in the digital world. And this was by no means a quick decision.

I scrapped the DSLR and used the money to fund part of my foray into the rangefinder world. It's a matter of "checks and balances". Confused I haven't looked back, and I am pursuing what is best for me, and for my current interests.

I think that, if you have a scanner in mind, that is simply another point in favor of what you are pondering.

My fascination with the old manual focus lenses for an SLR is very well satisfied with the (full frame) Revueflex 3003 film camera and the M42 lens group. That gives me more satisfaction than when I cobbled the lenses onto the K110D.


Zuletzt bearbeitet von Laurence am Mo Nov 10, 2008 6:28 pm, insgesamt ein Mal bearbeitet


Reply

Larry makes a really good point.
You seem to really enjoy the old film cameras and trading in the K10D for a scanner sounds like it will enrich that aspect more than having a DSLR.
It's all about what you like to shoot the most (film or digi) Very Happy


Reply

F16SUNSHINE hat folgendes geschrieben::
Larry makes a really good point.
You seem to really enjoy the old film cameras and trading in the K10D for a scanner sounds like it will enrich that aspect more than having a DSLR.
It's all about what you like to shoot the most (film or digi) Very Happy


And therein lies another good point Andy - It's all about what you like to shoot the most (film or digi)

I wrestled with myself and my preconceived notion that "I shouldn't give up a DSLR that I just started using". I had a hard time deliberating that I should keep up with the latest and greatest technology.

But in the end...for NOW...my decision gives me good feelings. The digital world is changing, and the volatile prices are an ADVANTAGE for me...if I change again, and decide to push myself back to some DSLR, there will ALWAYS be something affordable to quench my new thirst. Laughing


Reply

F16SUNSHINE hat folgendes geschrieben::
Carsten did you buy a Nikon? Shocked

No, Andy. I'm a "Canon man". Wink
Nikon has sent me the D90 about three weeks ago and on Saturday I got the D60 from them for testing. I will send them back in about two weeks.
I quite like the D90 but the D60 really is a toy - perfect for beginners, because it's very easy and it produces great pics! But it small, light and just doesn't the way I want a cam to feel. Wink


Reply

Ahh.....I see
Well have fun with the toy!
It must be a little let down to test this one after testing the Planar 85 Wink


Reply

I have or have had a K10D, a *istD and a *istDL.. the latter was the best of the bunch in terms of weight, 'feel' and a nice big screen - vital for knowing whether you have taken a worthwhile picture! The K10D is great but heavy and clumsy and seems less able to calculate a good exposure with non Pentax-A F and FA lenses than either of the *ist models and the latter do FAR better when using non Pentax lenses, especially the *istDL which was the cheapest by far.. my only reservation about a *istDS as opposed to the *istDS2 is the tiny screen which can be a real pain when checking focus on a taken shot etc.?

Doug


Reply

I've been contemplating picking up a dS for an extra (small, light, high ISO) body. The K10 is just too heavy to carry on a regular basis IMO.

The dS seems perfect even though it doesn't have SR: good high ISO, pentaprism, good metering, darker focus screen stock, etc, etc. Oh, and cheap Laughing To me the downsides are use of AA batteries, imbalance with big/heavy lenses, and no SR.

The K2000d looks good but it's double the price of a used dS and it's still 10MP.

Jes, since you get to use it for a week, you have nothing to lose. I think after the week is up, you'll have a better idea of what's going to be best Smile


Reply

I have and use both the K10D and K100D. I often use them together shooting with two different lenses for convienience.
I like both cameras and have no problem between the very little quality difference between the K10D and K100D or the operation of the cameras.
However the K10D is 200% or more better than the K100D in so many ways, but those differences may never be used or seen by some users and not missed if never needed, if you follow my meaning.
Sometimes the K10D is 'Overkill' at other times the K100D isn't good enough, at other times both are useless and my Canon G5 can do it better. It is all about using the right camera for your needs and for the image you are trying to create.
Hope this helps or gives food for thought.
PS I see a mention of GX 100. I hope to get one this week, my friend's 1 year old example a a good price. he has bought the GX 200.
My friends GX 100 pics with the camera I am buying
http://ianskyphotosite.blogspot.com/2007/07/ricoh-gx-100.html
Ian is also a Canon 5D owner user but loves the results from the GX 100 and now 200 and his GRD II Same story - the right tool for the job you want to do.


Reply

I have both the Ds and the K10d. Almost all of my MF-shooting is with Ds, since it has a better stock focusing screen and the meter is more constant with MF-lenses (because of the better screen). Also for the high-ISO work I use Ds, due to the fact that it has a better noise characteristic @ASA1600 and it has the ASA3200-setting. And I love the fact that with Ds I can use TTL-flash with MF-lenses.

Other ways the K10d is the superior camera...

But I must say... I first got the Ds to act as a back-up, but now as I am more and more eager to use MF-lenses it has seen as much use as K10d or even more.


Reply

Shocked Seems I need to take some times DS , it will be dirt cheap and great fun !


Reply

Hi colleagues, thank you very much for so many recommendations and food for the brain.
I appreciate very much your opinions, and I've taken seriously all of them into consideration.

the_Suede hat folgendes geschrieben::

...
PS - I'm actually very happy to see that someone dares to say that they prioritize their own need and ergonomics in stead of always hunting for the highest MP figures and extreme ISO's... For me this only means that you care more about your pictures than your equipment. And to openly say so in this day and time is.... Kudos! Hope it works out for the best. DS


That's currently my main concern. If I cannot shot good pictures with a simpler camera, it's not worth to improve to a better one just to get bad pictures with better quality...

F16SUNSHINE hat folgendes geschrieben::
I say try it and see.
... I would add however that the K10D is maybe a better processor regardless of pixel count.
Clean images at higher ISO's with better dynamic range seem to be what you are most at risk of losing by moving down.


Thanks Andy, I really misconsidered this point. Dynamic range is what I love from film, so it has to be an additional point in the final consideration.

peterqd hat folgendes geschrieben::

Me2. A Spottie with a 6Mp digital back would be ideal! Smile


A long time dream for me too Smile

LucisPictor hat folgendes geschrieben::
Hi, Jes!
Have fun testing the differences.
For me, it would be the K10D.
If I were to buy a Pentax DSLR, it would be a K10D or a K20D.

Once I got to know the heft and feel of my 40D, I do not want to go back to a small cam. Wink My 2c.
After I was playing around with the Nikon D90, I got the D60 yesterday. It just feels like a toy...


You're right, Carsten. The K10D seems to be much stronger and weather proof. I have to take this also into consideration because I live next to the sea and its proximity does nothing good to the equipment...

poilu hat folgendes geschrieben::

you could also stay with only one dslr. You already have your GX100 as backup


I must say "touché", Poilu...
But the GX100 is a different breed. I've got it for more than one year, and it's definitely my third eye. It comes with me wherever I go. I owned several compact cameras prior to the GX100, but none lasted with me more than a few weeks. But the GX100 is very different, and I like it a lot. For sure is the camera I most use. And if one day fails, I hope to find another one exactly the same.
Keeping two SLRs: I keep the Canon because I already own it and can support most of the lenses I got. But I moved to Pentax to have focus confirmation on the body and better (less) noise at lower ISO.
You are rigth. One SLR should be enough. You cannot shot with two of them at once Smile.

Orio hat folgendes geschrieben::
Jes, a K10D is in my future plans... but unfortunately not now Sad


Orio, you will like it.

Riku hat folgendes geschrieben::

Why have Pentax at all if not for the Shake Reduction? Having steady hands just means that you will get more out of the SR.


Having focus confirmation for all the MF lenses is a great reason to me....

Laurence hat folgendes geschrieben::


Whoa, I didn't know you had the GX100 Jes...

Perhaps just keep that GX100 (what a BEAUTY), and scrap the DSLR venue. Shocked

...
I scrapped the DSLR and used the money to fund part of my foray into the rangefinder world. It's a matter of "checks and balances". Confused I haven't looked back, and I am pursuing what is best for me, and for my current interests.

I think that, if you have a scanner in mind, that is simply another point in favor of what you are pondering.

My fascination with the old manual focus lenses for an SLR is very well satisfied with the (full frame) Revueflex 3003 film camera and the M42 lens group. That gives me more satisfaction than when I cobbled the lenses onto the K110D.


Larry,
DSLrs are different beasts. With the GX100 you cannot get the small DOF you are used to on the big sisters. No bokeh, no fun.
But for sure is a capable camera, the best compact camera I ever owned.

F16SUNSHINE hat folgendes geschrieben::
Larry makes a really good point.
You seem to really enjoy the old film cameras and trading in the K10D for a scanner sounds like it will enrich that aspect more than having a DSLR.
It's all about what you like to shoot the most (film or digi) Very Happy


Andy: yes, it's a good point. I love shooting film, but I learn more quickly with Digital. Let's say half and half. Always shooting film being more rewarding. My learning curve is better satisfied with a digital cam because I can get instant feedback. (My memory is not very good). So I use digital to learn, film to enjoy.

nemesis101 hat folgendes geschrieben::
I have or have had a K10D, a *istD and a *istDL.. the latter was the best of the bunch in terms of weight, 'feel' and a nice big screen - vital for knowing whether you have taken a worthwhile picture! The K10D is great but heavy and clumsy and seems less able to calculate a good exposure with non Pentax-A F and FA lenses than either of the *ist models and the latter do FAR better when using non Pentax lenses, especially the *istDL which was the cheapest by far.. my only reservation about a *istDS as opposed to the *istDS2 is the tiny screen which can be a real pain when checking focus on a taken shot etc.?

Doug


Thanks Dough, that's really another weak point that I was not considering.

ryan s hat folgendes geschrieben::
I've been contemplating picking up a dS for an extra (small, light, high ISO) body. The K10 is just too heavy to carry on a regular basis IMO.

The dS seems perfect even though it doesn't have SR: good high ISO, pentaprism, good metering, darker focus screen stock, etc, etc. Oh, and cheap Laughing To me the downsides are use of AA batteries, imbalance with big/heavy lenses, and no SR.

The K2000d looks good but it's double the price of a used dS and it's still 10MP.

Jes, since you get to use it for a week, you have nothing to lose. I think after the week is up, you'll have a better idea of what's going to be best Smile


Ryan,
Nice description, it makes me feel that the istDs would suffit... I'm testing it already.
And what I can lose is money Smile I migth be tempted of ending keeping both.... Wink.


Rob Leslie hat folgendes geschrieben::
I have and use both the K10D and K100D. I often use them together shooting with two different lenses for convienience.
I like both cameras and have no problem between the very little quality difference between the K10D and K100D or the operation of the cameras.
However the K10D is 200% or more better than the K100D in so many ways, but those differences may never be used or seen by some users and not missed if never needed, if you follow my meaning.
Sometimes the K10D is 'Overkill' at other times the K100D isn't good enough, at other times both are useless and my Canon G5 can do it better. It is all about using the right camera for your needs and for the image you are trying to create.
Hope this helps or gives food for thought.
PS I see a mention of GX 100. I hope to get one this week, my friend's 1 year old example a a good price. he has bought the GX 200.
My friends GX 100 pics with the camera I am buying
http://ianskyphotosite.blogspot.com/2007/07/ricoh-gx-100.html
Ian is also a Canon 5D owner user but loves the results from the GX 100 and now 200 and his GRD II Same story - the right tool for the job you want to do.


Rob, thanks for your comment. More in favour of my argument above (temptation of keeping both).

soikka hat folgendes geschrieben::
I have both the Ds and the K10d. Almost all of my MF-shooting is with Ds, since it has a better stock focusing screen and the meter is more constant with MF-lenses (because of the better screen). Also for the high-ISO work I use Ds, due to the fact that it has a better noise characteristic @ASA1600 and it has the ASA3200-setting. And I love the fact that with Ds I can use TTL-flash with MF-lenses.

Other ways the K10d is the superior camera...

But I must say... I first got the Ds to act as a back-up, but now as I am more and more eager to use MF-lenses it has seen as much use as K10d or even more.


So more arguments in favor of the istDS.... That's becoming difficult!!.. Wink

Attila hat folgendes geschrieben::
Shocked Seems I need to take some times DS , it will be dirt cheap and great fun !


For sure, Attila. In the spanish Pentax forum are being sold by 180 ~ 200 €.

Thanks again to everybody, I'm almost convinced of keeping only the istDS, (but I feel difficult to get rid of the K10D). Smile

Kind regards,
Jes.


Reply

Jesito

Shooting with two DSLRs or Film SLRs is the way to go. Nothing is quicker or easier than having two similar cameras with different lenses ready to shoot. I have shot with two (Sometimes 3) bodies all through my film days, even when using MF in a studio and on location 2 bodies were the norm
The P & S of course fits in the pocket (If you can really call a GX 100 a P & S) just as the rangefinder compact always did in the film days.
When I began shooting DSLR I always missed the easy flow of using 2 bodies but cost had to be considered. Today a second DSLR body cost less than the film versions used to. Most regular shooters I know work the same way. Even my neighbour who only shoots on sunny weekends has a D50 and D70 and always has both round his neck.
If any wonders how you shoot two DSLR bodies. Very simple, you adjust the straps so both hang round your neck one above the other without touching.

PS If you can take good images with a GX 100 you should have no real problem with any DSLR


Reply

I've had a K10D in addition to my DS.

I sold the K10D and stayed with the DS.

The K10D's advantages (for me) are onyl the SR and perhaps wheather sealing.
The differences in resolution are neglible for me.

Advantages of the DS are already written:
- lightweight but nevertheless solid
- better metering with non-A-lenses
- flash-metering with older flashes...

and if I want to use bigger lenses with my DS:
I've bought the Dicain-grip for these situations...